The Olive Oil Shops

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  CB
5 months ago
Considering how much we love to cook we should have bought a lot more, but can always come back next time.There are a ton of different olive oil options and probably all of them are good, but I like to keep things simple for when we cook. The lady was nice and gave us a sample of different oils to try.

  Kim McAuliffe
a month ago
We just stopped into this cute shop today! Wonderful woman running it and owning it!Stop in for these plant-based items and many, many other items.She even has stonewall kitchen

  Stacy Hennerley
5 months ago
Love this shop! I don't get my oil or vinegars from anywhere else. They also have a great art selection on the walls so it's always fun to go and see what's new. If you're in the area definitely stop by and get some top notch products!

  Frank DeMartino
7 years ago
Another one of my favorite Lake Geneva spots, this small storefront hosts a ton of oils that will give a kick to anything from salads to fruit and meats. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable, and they always have rotating inventory. They are generous with samples, so if you see something you are curious about, give it a try!

  Nena Starks
10 months ago
We LOVE this store. We travel from Illinois to stock up on olive oil, lotion and soap. This is a fun store that has a variety of items made with olive oil. Particularly, olive oil infused with different flavors. Must check out if you are in the area!

  Momo
2 weeks ago
Website said they close at 5:00pm on Sundays, drove an hour and a half, made it there at 3:50 and they closed at 4:00, had I gotten there 10 minutes later, would not have been good.Update your hours

  k
7 months ago
We arrived at the store and began to browse. There was a woman at the back of the store who was on a phone call. She didn't greet us or even acknowledge our presence in any way.We will not return.

  Ben Tweet
a year ago
Pay no mind to the old reviews, the service here is exceptional! Was in today to pick up some gifts and was greeted right away and given excellent recommendations. Have been using these oils for many years and they are always delicious and of excellent quality, as well as very reasonably priced. Highly recommend!

  Ethan Z
a year ago
There were so many olive oils and balsamic vinegars to choose from. The prices were reasonable for the size for the bottles. The people were really nice and it turns out that they ship anywhere in the US.

  Traci Alonzo
5 years ago
OMG!!! This placid is ridiculous!First of all, the owner is the sweetest person in the world. We were vacationing and the name sounded interesting. So we go in and there is a whole store full of different infused olive oil that you can sample. Anything you can think of and more. When you go in and turn to the right where the sink is is pure olive oil soaps that smell delicious! Wildflower is a good one. I bought the lavender bar soap and lotion which is really a body butter. I would have bought more but it was my last day and I was on a budget. However she does have a website so...I'm going to start now and save money so I can go back in the spring and stay a few days and shop some more. But, you have to go. It's intoxicating.

  Ryan Marshall (Ryno)
3 years ago
Amazing flavors! I recommend the Tuscan Herb infused olive oil, it's a main staple in my home. And even though masks are required/recommended, the smile you're always greeted with is very obvious. Thanks always for the amazing service and products!

  Sarah Heim
4 years ago
First time visiting this store. My husband and I weren't greeted at all the lady at the counter was on the phone and clearly you can tell it was a personal call. Bought one bottle of garlic olive oil would have bought more, but since she was on the phone the whole time we couldn't get any help or questions answered etc. Even during checkout she was still on the phone. Didn't ever say hello, thank you, come again etc. Definitely need to work on your customer service skills.

  Karen Zehnder
4 years ago
I was there on Saturday with my sisters, they were not scheduled to open until 10 o clock but the lady was there the door was unlocked so she let us in very friendly and knowledgeable lady and delicious oils and vinegar. I bought the raspberry balsamic for the 2nd time and trying the watermelon, I will be back again for sure this year or next. Great variety also and you can taste as many as you want before purchasing.

  Stephy Miehle
2 years ago
Lovely flavored olive oils and vinegars! The pear balsamic is my favorite. There are also olive oil soaps, pickles, spreads, and snack items perfect for a charcuterie board. Don't forget to bring back your punch card!

  T Burdick
4 years ago
Great/friendly customer service and great gift opportunities! Purchased a few things for Father's Day gifts and I'm really tempted to keep them for myself! It's always fun walking into a shop that offers samples as well!

  Zahra Khudeira
8 years ago
I had a very good experience at this shop. The store has olive oils from all over the world. You can sample the oils and balsamic vinegars before you buy. The sales lady was very friendly and helpful. I will be returning to this shop soon.

  Justin Etnyre
a year ago
First time in a shop dedicated to olive oil and basalmic vinegar. Good selection and a knowledgeable person behind the counter. Glad we walked in there

  DK
4 years ago
Large selection of infused vinegars and oils. Tasting available for all varieties. Chefs and cooking novices will appreciate a stop in this unique shoppe.

  Jim Coach Krupke
a year ago
AWESOME shop loaded with tons of inventory! Plenty of other products available too! The owner is AMAZING

  Erin Johnson
7 years ago
Wow - walked in here with my kids and talk about unwelcome. Right when we walked in, one of the employees (possibly owners) greeted us with a Shhhhh! And tried to play off as a joke. I didn't spend a fortune $50 between my MIL and I and as we left I said "thank you", and nothing in response. We won't be coming back.

  Tony Lauth
2 years ago
Great people to deal with. The best garlic infused balsamic vinegar.I highly recommend giving them a try.

  Erica Morgan
6 years ago
I absolutely love this quaint shop! Everything you could dream of in and olive oil and vinegar! Please open a shop in Chicago

  Shaun Kelly
6 years ago
Lot of variety of flavored oils and vinagers, the lady being the counter is always nice, and informative

  A Piper
5 years ago
Looked decent but wasn't sure about a few things. The person working the counter never acknowledged are presence at all.

  MsVan P Hebert
3 years ago
Quality product with excellent variety: along with a well informed friendly proprietor.

  Athena Clifford
6 years ago
Very nice owner, outstanding olive oil and bath products...

  Garrett Pfarr
8 years ago
Good oil is a great way to flavor your cooking

  Up Town
3 years ago
They know what is what. And great pairing for all flavors

  Sid & Nidhi Bansal
3 years ago
Great selection of vinegars

  James Ritchey
6 years ago
Nice and friendly place and not to expensive.