Manypenny Bistro

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Neal Erickson
a month ago
More

  debbie
8 months ago
More

  Nate Wilson (Organic Squirrel)
a month ago
More

  Leann Dove
7 months ago
We were just in town for the weekend and had no idea where to eat. Randomly walked in Friday night and received excellent food and service! We enjoyed it so much we went back for breakfast the next morning! That time we sat on the porch where the ordering system is different and you order at the window instead of having a server. Everything went smoothly and we enjoyed that experience as well! All the food was fresh and delicious!

  Jessica Kampa
9 months ago
Stopped at Manypenny Bistro for lunch before heading home after a camping trip on Madeline Island. We chose it based on location and the fact that it had a high rating.We were greeted when we came in and told we could sit anywhere. We sat at a table and were looking at menus when a guy came over and told us we had to move, that table was reserved. Ummmm . We were told to sit anywhere.After looking over the menu, I ordered one of the specials, the blackened whitefish sandwich, my husband ordered the other special, blackened whitefish tacos, and our daughter ordered the chicken bacon wrap.As we waited for our food, it was difficult to carry on a conversation. The acoustics did not lend themselves to being able to hear each other well.Our food came out in a timely manner. My husband was missing the salsa served with his chips but our waitress quickly corrected that error.Our daughter really loved her wrap it was STUFFED with chicken and tomatoes and ranch (she held the lettuce).My husband and I both loved the kick of spice on our whitefish, but we both found it way too salty and both of us like salty food. My husband left the tortilla chips on his plate as he said they were inedibly stale. We loved the concepts of the sandwich and the tacos, which were similar in many ways, but the salt level on these meals needs to be corrected.The waitress was nice and took care of us, as expected.I might try Manypenny again but choose a different meal.

  Michael Hammock
7 months ago
More

  Kristin Stark
2 months ago
Have ordered takeout two times here. Chicken strips dinner was pretty good, pizza even better. Some of the best pizza I have had. Delivery was cheap and quick. Would order here again and looking forward to enjoying the pizza again! It's thin crust Chicago style pub cut (small squares) which I absolutely love. Sauce is great and pizza cooked perfectly.Kid-friendliness: They have a kids menu here.

  Erich Thalacker
3 months ago
None of the food was good and some of it bad.Some of the worst sauces I have had. Service not great either.1 star - Would not go back, wish I had money back

  Theresa E
8 months ago
We enjoyed a very nice lunch at the Manypenny Bistro after a morning stroll through the quaint town of Bayfield. One cheeseburger and one gyro both at decent prices and tasty, too, to satisfy our hunger. And all employees at the bistro were courteous, helpful, and pleasant. Thank you, Manypenny Bistro!

  Anita Y
a year ago
More

  Hannah Tindall
7 months ago
More

  John Clark
a year ago
We are at Manypenny Bistro for a late lunch early dinner as we had just gotten into town after a long travel day. We had seen the reviews and figured it would be good. The food was very good, we had the seafood wrap and bbq sandwich. Definitely recommend the food it was very good. Can t say the same for the staff. Our waitress was on us from the time we came in wanting us to order. We needed time to review the menu but she can to our table 3 times. After our food was served she never came to check how we were doing. We found out she had to go to the post office and asked someone else to assist us. Never had that happen before. I don t think she ever told us her name. She seemed in a hurry and didn t really care to be there. Also no one told us paying by credit card there was a fee. At least tell us in advance so if we did have cash we could have the option to pay differently. I would go here again but not have the same waitress.

  Sue Ann Jaffarian
10 months ago
We came here for Sunday brunch and loved it! Everything was so delicious and fresh, and our waitress Shana rocked. This was our fourth restaurant during our stay in Bayfield, yet the only one that offered excellent service. If not for leaving the next day, we would ve eaten there again, hands-down. My friend had the mushroom and cheese omelette, which was huge and fluffy. I had the grilled badger, which was a scrambled egg and ham breakfast sandwich served on cranberry wild rice bread with a special sauce for dipping or spreading. We both had what they call toss potatoes, which are perfectly seasoned and cooked home fries. Best meal we had in Bayfield!

  Steve Moses
a year ago
We came in to town and stumbled upon this place. We were looking for breakfast and we found Manypenny Bistro. It s a great place to sit back and relax, enjoy coffee or tea, and have a wonderful breakfast. The service and the food were both very good. The homemade breads and jams are excellent.

  Freddy James
a year ago
Enjoy the breakfast and supper because we did both The breakfast was delicious, my wife had smoked trout Benedict and loved it! The next night we tried supper and i had the pizza, yummy and my wife had the blackened wite fish with baby red taters, really good recommended stop, enjoy

  Michelle Pryor
a month ago
More

  Stacia Gregory
7 months ago
More

  Mitch Lac
a month ago
More

  Nick Ellingson
a year ago
We stopped in for dinner on a Sunday at 4pm, we were immediately seated and given waters and a menu.I ordered the Whitefish Reuben with fries and it had all the flavor of a classic reuben, and was both filling and light thanks to the crispy white fish filet.My partner had the Smoked Trout salad, the generous serving of sweet, smokey trout complimented the fresh greens and veggies of this quality salad.We would recommend this great bistro to anyone looking for a great bite to eat!Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options are available.

  L Owen
10 months ago
We ate breakfast here two days during our 3-day stay in Bayfield - the best veggie omelet, raspberry-wild rice toast, great coffee and wonderful service. A great place to get filled up for the day!

  Brad Butch Colburn
a year ago
We went twice, 1st time fir a late 10:00 breakfast and the other was a 7:30 breakfast. Food and service were great both times! I had the Italian sausage smothered hashbrowns and my wife had the Fisherman's plate. The cran-raspberry jam was great!

  Michael Hecker
2 years ago
We tried Manypenny again for breakfast and found the service and breakfast much better than our first visit for lunch. I had the Raspberry French toast which was very good.Lunch - Some of the locals recommended this place for lunch. We were disappointed by the slow service. We ordered the large pizza and it was faster than the other menu items. This made sense for a family of seven adults. It was average quality and service below average.

  Courtney Meyer
a month ago
More

  Mike Burkhamer
5 months ago
More

  Diane Kestner
a year ago
Excellent service! Whitefish tacos were amazing ( went back the next day for another lunch). The pizza was one of our favorites, with a thin crust, Zesty sauce, many toppings and lotza cheese!

  Farah Ali
2 years ago
AMAZING BREAKFAST PLACE!!!We were in Bay field for the long weekend and loved it. Tried a bunch of local restaurants and Manypenny was our favorite . We went there three times in two days and enjoyed our food there every single time.Our first experience was breakfast and it was oh so good. The eggs Benedict was one of the best I have ever had. We ordered the eggs Benedict , veggie and bay omelet, Pancakes and hot chocolate. The portions were huge and the food was fantastic.We returned back here to pick up lunch . We got the Buffalo chicken pizza, cheese pizza, falafel wrap and veggie burger. Again all of them were so well prepared and delicious .The service is good, but they are incredibly busy so be prepared to wait but so worth the wait.Go check out Many Penny in Bayfield, WI!!!

  Karen Peterson
8 months ago
More

  Rip Williams
7 months ago
Food and service were both excellent! The staff was decidedly welcoming, fun, and friendly even serving through the window into the front room. All of the food, to a person (6x for dinner) was prepared accurately, and the menu has some true eclectic gems. Try shaved lamb on top of a burger, or any of the other creative yummies! Bayfield has its share of food/watering holes, and this one absolutely shouldn't be missed.

  Jamie Nestroyl
8 months ago
More

  Mike
a year ago
More