Reviews
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Tammy Stouffer
a month ago
More
Inge Burbank
5 months ago
Serving up oversized portions of semi-bland bar fare. My family stopped by for the cheese steak sandwiches, which were okay - but we were only able to eat half and leave the rest since we were on the road. Potato chip brand definitely needs an upgrade to something more flavorful. Good prices, but am hoping the kitchen manager might work on some improvements when it comes to flavor and portion size.
Crystal
4 months ago
Absolutely love grabbing takeout here. Possibly the best California cheesesteak currently available in the area. I also love the Italian grinder. Sometimes it's loud and hard to get your order heard over the phone but it's a bar so if it's extremely detailed you may want to go in. Always get someone different answering but for the most part everyone is pleasant and knows most menu items. Like I said I'm ordering takeout so I can't speak on dinning in which is normally a different experience an better service but I would definitely try their hoagies and sandwiches either way
Joy Kahler
8 months ago
More
Carol Grove
a year ago
More
Bonnie Roush
a year ago
We decided to try something new and were here on Sunday for lunch. We sat in the dining room instead of the bar area. The server was very polite and our food came out pretty quickly. We got the nacho plate as an appetizer which was yummy!! We were most of the way done when our food came out so it was perfect timing. She refilled our glasses. He got a bacon cheeseburger and I had a reuben and we both got fries. We left feeling very full and satisfied.
John L Blackstock
a year ago
Very disappointing!! We heard so much about the prime rib. Server had an attitude and nobody including the kitchen could tell us the size of the prime offerings. We were told the cook would weigh the meat for us. That was cool??? I ordered med-rare. I got med-well-burnt-burnt. Don't believe I've ever eaten pure leather before...that was a first. Shame I don't have better things to say about the historic Millheim!!!
Brad Gentzel
a year ago
More
Carol Fultz
8 months ago
Waitress was very nice. Had a lot going on with the restaurant. She was waitressing and cooking. So she was very relaxed for how things were.Food & drinks: Very reasonable in prices.
Tim Brickley
2 years ago
What a great place. Made this one of our stops on the 16th annual St. PATRICK'S Day pub crawl. OUTSTANDING!!!! The regulars were great, bought us a round of drinks, then the owner bought us drinks, plus gave us two platters of cheese french fries. Definitely a place we will visit throughout the coming year. Five thumbs up for the Millheim Hotel.
Tommy Oren
a year ago
Great place to stop and have a meal. The people are super friendly. Can not express enough how nice everyone was. The atmosphere was so pleasant and friendly. The hotel is by no means a 5 star hotel. It's like stepping back into the past. Millheim was established in the late 1700s. They have managed to maintain an old time feel to the town and the surroundings. Don't come here looking for the latest and greatest. They have a modern feel in an old timey setting. And of course this is Amish country so you better never get in a hurry on the highways. You will most likely be behind an Amish horse and buggy all most every where you go. Do try out all of the local foods including the menu at the Millheim Hotel. Amish stores and foods can be found all over the valley. Start your morning out at the local coffee shop called the Inglebean. Great coffee and amazing bagels, fresh eggs, sausage and ham. Super friendly staff. Will definitely be returning to the Millheim in the future. Such a great place to visit.
Brandi Jefferis
2 years ago
Food was good. My 1st time in here or even in this town everyone was very nice and I enjoyed the company. Will return any time I'm in this area. It's great that this was a very inviting place to eat and I felt quite comfortable.
Kevin Vandermark
6 months ago
Great food great price great atmosphere.
Joey Neary
2 years ago
Played a show here. Place was nice and clean. Staff and customers were all very kind. Ill definitely stop back when im out this way. The big pretzel was absolutely phenomenal!
Cierra Haynie
5 years ago
Some of the employees are petty af. BUT the owners are good people and the food is good. I recommend Thursday nights. Great bartender worth visiting. He goes by Striver and he is one of the nicest people I've ever met. Good conversation and great service from him.
mike dehoff
2 years ago
More
Andy Krishak
2 years ago
Wow... haven't been here for years...last time for dinner was a disappointment, but this place had turned around. Remodeled, great bartender, food was good and huge portions.. gonna be back...
Jon Ribbing
a year ago
More
Siri Ream
5 years ago
Definitely a home town feel. But for being above a bar it's pretty quiet. Community bathrooms and some of the rooms air-conditioning doesn't work. But for the price, its a good deal. Plus the balcony is nice.
Terry Wenker
4 years ago
Outstanding food options with the specials every week awesome wings every Monday night the staff is awesome from the cook to the bartender to the waiter to the waitress kind of like an m&m song at this point but it's all good
steve hughes
5 years ago
If you just need a place to sleep it will do. Didn't try the food or check out the bar. So no comments on those. Rooms have no TV's and bathrooms are community bathrooms in the hallway. Two locks on the room door and neither of them worked. You could just push the door open. Wouldn't suggest this place for a family. But for adults passing through who would like to spend a night in the bar and have a place to sleep afterwards it wouldn't be bad. Rooms are quiet but building needs improvement.
Dave Romanyshyn
a month ago
More
Chris Mastrocola
5 years ago
It's always a great place to go to get together with friends and have some good food and drink. The wait staff is always there to help you have a great experience. And Chris is the bomb!
Karl Wiltrout
9 years ago
The Millheim is worth the cheap rate if your just looking for a place to sleep. Nothing fancy. The 2 restrooms have showers which rate low. I go to stay during fishing trips but I would never take my family. The restaurant is pretty good and there is a bar which is pretty much for the younger crowd but I never had any problems. Just sleep,fish,eat and hit the sack.
Heather
3 years ago
Beautiful old hotel. Great food. Pretty good service considering the lady was the only person working with our party of 4 and about 4 more at the bar.
Bryan Stover
a year ago
Always a great atmosphere, friendly staff, good prices and good home cooking.
Lenny Hockenberry
3 years ago
Great place. Excellent food. Great service and good cold beer. Stop in and try it for yourself.
Matthew Caswell
4 years ago
More
Lisa Alley (Lisa)
2 years ago
Amazing crew that owns and runs the place. Could not have been more hospitable. Definitely a cool spot!!!
Jere Murr
4 years ago
Good food ,friendly bartender named Shriver. Pizza night is Wensday. Great Hawaii pizza. Will go back for sure!!!