Keystone Arms Inc.

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Devon Goddard
4 months ago
Joe is a really nice guy and He treats me well from the moment I walk in till I walk out. Prices are good too

  Mike Tantillo
5 months ago
Keystone arms in matamoras pa is just awesome!! Joe the owner and Tony and Krystal are all great people and I highly recommend doing business with them!!

  Dean Colomban
5 months ago
Great place. Great inventory and prices.Unfortunately if you live in NY they cannot sell to you.

  Pete Fontana
5 months ago
5 stars in advance Can you sell ammo to a NY resident who holds a PA pistol permit?

  zev tabak
4 months ago
Great place, great customer service, great guy very Knowledgeable

  Lillian Tantillo (GS)
3 weeks ago
Very friendly owner and they always make you feel welcomed!! They have a awesome selection of firearms ammo and accessories. You won't be dissapointed!!!!

  Jeff Tuern
7 months ago
This company likes to pretend that they're not related to the Keystone Arms in Hillsville. I guess that makes sense, if you ignore that they have nearly identical names, and post up photos on Gunbroker using the same background, same resolution, etc.I guess the other possibility is that FFLs in PA simply have no creativity in names, and magically stumble upon using the same photography style. Sure, that seems wholly plausible.In either case, terrible company. And deceitful.

  ABC Traveler
10 months ago
DO NOT send your consignment items to him. He is a shyster. Sold my guns promised he keeps only a percentage but after they got sold, he kept all the money and told me if your items don t sell for more than a certain amount, I keep all the funds . That rule is not on their gunbroker page neither on their website. They are a fraud. Do yourself a favor and send your consignments somewhere else.

  Matt Mann
2 years ago
Joe is brutally honest and a good guy! He won't bs you and he can back up what he says. I bought my first shotgun from him years ago and I always go back! Worth the trip

  Commander-RR
3 years ago
When no one else could get me supplies, this awesome guy could and did. Extremely friendly the first time meeting him. A very down to earth American helping to support our freedoms. Would definitely shop here again. You will not be sorry dealing with this gentleman.

  Charming Hostilities
a year ago
Going to assume this Keystone, and the other Keystone in Hillsville are related.Either way, they need someone new to work on their Gunbroker listings. Absolutely everything is "RARE" "UNIQUE" "AWESOME" or some synonym, as if people can't figure that out unless they shout it at them on literally every single listing. "RARE AND DESIRED Glock"If you keep claiming everything is unique and rare....after a while, nothing feels like it is.Unless you like being told that something is desirable. It's just weird. Feels like a high schooler can't get out of their thesaurus to write better posts, so they just use superlatives non stop.

  Harry Mann
2 years ago
I just don't understand the 5 star reviews for Joe and his gun shop. He has a terrible reputation at every local gun club and gun shop. To be fair I've only had one interaction at his store. He's one of those shops that was willing to bump ammo prices up as far as he could, ala CheaperThanDirt.Com. He wanted to charge me almost $60 for range 9mm and that was after getting mad at me for simply showing up at his shop.Best I've ever heard about Joe is from a local gun club friend who knew Joe since he was 10 years old on Staten Island. He said Joe was no good then and he's no good now.

  M Worley
6 years ago
I absolutely love going here. Aside from the fact I've been doing business exclusively for almost a year, when my wife was ready to purchase her first pistol, the gentleman she dealt with addressed her and dealt exclusively with her for over an hour to help her make the best decision for her. That's a huge aspect of what's continued my business relationship with them for all this time. They may not be the most cost worthy game in town, but they are certainly the most attentive to what the customers needs are, and that will always beat out cost for me. If you're in the market for anything, do stop in to visit them as they can get their hands on almost anything.

  Lewis Schnauble
4 years ago
I visited their shop today from Maryland. Everyone was very helpful. The owner gave me a lot of information about my gun and told me to give him a call if I needed any help. Highly recommend !

  Paolo Insinga
5 years ago
hard to get a hold of but great people. they are busy busy but hey that's what happens when your good and you help people they keep coming back. A+ if you dony know nothing about guns yourll be a expert after leaving this place

  brian vaughan
3 years ago
Awesome people. Very knowledgeable. Had an excellent experience shopping with them. Will definitely shop here again.

  Rich W
4 years ago
Five stars aren't enough to give this place. Friendly and knowledgeable staff and owner, top dollar offered if you're selling, fair prices if you're buying.

  Mark McKeon
8 years ago
Treated very fairly on a trade with no nonsense. Pleased with my new purchase as well. Great customer service. Would shop there again.

  Christopher Bucca
4 years ago
I was just passing through, so I poked my nose in here. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. Nice prices as far as I could tell.

  Thomas Jacobus
5 years ago
I have been a customer for 19 year's. Buy & sell they take care of you personally. My last purchase was of a old gun in great shape.

  Scott Nietupski
2 years ago
Definitely worth the stop it's great when you're talked to the owner and he has a lot of knowledge I'll be back again

  Dom Rovito
5 years ago
Small place, but they have a nice selection and some interesting pieces. Guys were very pleasant and knowledgeable.

  mtandiz
5 months ago
The bestest place ever

  Fred Vobis
3 years ago
Joe is knowledgeable, helpful and has high end products. A pleasure to do business with!

  Marc Kube
6 years ago
Friendly owner who quickly solved a problem I was having with a shotgun. Great selection and great service!

  James Sarte
4 years ago
Joe's a great guy. I use him for all my NFA purchases.

  Richard Drew
5 years ago
Great customer service. They go out of their way to satisfy their customers.

  Angelo Palmieri
3 years ago
Very insightful owner, really knows his firearms definitely going to come back.

  Jason Oliver
6 years ago
Great prices great guys! My Wife and I love this shop!

  Francisco Soto
7 years ago
Great shop. Fantastic friendly people. Very welcome feeling.