Mister Smith's Garage

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  A. S.
7 months ago
We have been going to Mister Smiths Garage for years. He has inspected and worked on 3 vehicles over these years and has always been honest and upfront with us about any work that needed done or was going to need done in the near future. His staff has always been kind when talking to them on the phone or in person. We will definitely keep returning for all of our vehicles.

  Heather McCartney
7 years ago
Most trustworthy mechanic ever. This garage is run by the best people. They go out of their way to help you, staying late on a Saturday, keeping you updated on the progress while you wait. They do great work, always honest about the prices upfront. The owner is so genuine and answers all your questions. One time, they had a puppy there, which was pretty great. I moved out about 40 minutes away from Rochester, and I still keeping coming back. for the great service.

  Bill Fox
7 months ago
T.J. does good work at a fair price. He's a straight shooter, and won't sell you a repair that you don't need.

  Marlene Yates
a month ago
Vary friendly and they can help with any problems you may have

  jeremy glass
3 years ago
I don't often take the time to write reviews, but looking for an honest and reliable mechanic is such a challenge these days I felt I had to let everyone know that Mr. Smith's garage was up front, knowledgeable, honest and quick with their work. I couldn't be happier. Thanks.

  Andrea Rigby
9 years ago
Mr Smith (TJ,) his father before him, and the staff, have done routine services (oil changes, inspections) as well as some significant repairs on my vehicle for the past four years. The shop is honest, does quality work, and goes a step beyond for his customers. (He once had his receptionist drive myself and my two preschoolers to our home in his own vehicle because my vehicle needed to be left at the shop and worked on immediately. He even helped me install my preschoolers' car seats.)I HIGHLY RECOMMEND THIS SHOP!**I am not related, or know Mr Smith, other than he is my mechanic. This shop was recommended to me by a few friends who also think highly of the shop.**

  Karla Schell
9 years ago
Mr. Smith's garage has been great to me. It can be quite daunting to find a good mechanic, but Mr. Smith's works with their customers delivering fast, affordable service at a reasonable price. They go out of their way to help customers and provide outstanding service.

  Anthony Barrick (Anthony Barrick)
4 years ago
When I was having trouble finding a place to inspect my Tesla (yes a lot of places say NO to Tesla Vehicles) TJ was more than welcome to take care of me. He was very interested in learning about the car. Inspection, Tires changed and balanced. Would Highly recommend. I prefer to take my car to someone who is a true car guy.

  T. J. LANE
3 years ago
Mr. Smith's Garage has always delivered on installation of quality parts and the service is outstanding. Fare prices and will not sell you a part if not needed. When I need parts and service Mr. Smith's Garage is my first and only call.

  Outraged Consumer
3 years ago
The vehicle was inspected at this garage.1. First I was hit with repairs that are not required under the PA Vehicle Equipment and Inspection Regulations.2. Then when the vehicle was returned to me it was found that a brake caliper that was removed during repairs, was reinstalled missing one of the 2 bolts that holds it in place!MAJOR SAFETY ISSUE.A novice would realize they are missing a bolt during reassembly.How does a garage not reinstall critical fasteners and not realize it ???OR NOT SAY SOMETHING.3. Also, a hard brake fluid line was snapped during the process, creating a slow leak, leaving the owner with NO BRAKES when an hour from home !!!!! Then when MISTER SMITH"S GARAGE was contacted about the missing bolt the owner, TJ, acted like it was no big deal, they would replace it and would even do the hard brake line while it was there. BUT he was going to charge me for 5 minutes it takes to replace a brake line, REALLY? When I have to waste MY TIME to bring the vehicle back to install MISSING PARTS ????Prime example of shoddy work and sleazy garage. Deserves NO STARS

  John Hollenberger
4 years ago
This is an honest shop. We recently had an engine failure and the staff was very honest and upfront with the issue. They also helped us trouble shoot an issue with another car at no cost as it took them only 5 to determine and fix the problem. Highly recommend this place.

  Cary Pearson
a year ago
They really take care of my mother and go out of their way to help her get back and forth. Very fortunate for them to assist her.

  Felicia Mycyk
6 years ago
He worked on my old vechiles and My new vehicle. I am amazed that he can Remember details without even having the information in front of him. I drive pass a number of repair shops to come to Mister Smith's garage because I know I can trust what he does.

  Chuck Goulding
a year ago
Excellent service, they took great care of our emergency repairs

  Jocelyn Hill
4 years ago
I have been a customer for years. They are always accommodating and very polite. Quick, high-quality work in a clean facility. They stand out from other shops!

  John Lyman
6 years ago
Very happy to have found this place! I never ventured towards Rochester but since my shop is on freedom I found this garage. Nothing but good things to say about Mister Smith's Garage.

  Nancy O'Leary
2 years ago
i trust T.J. Smith to do what is needed to keep my car in good running conditio n A very nice place and trustworthy.

  Daisie Pontius
6 years ago
The job was done on time at the price he quotedll great customer service! being a single woman I would have definitely take my car back there again

  Nathan Wolfe
2 years ago
Very fair pricing. Very honest mechanic. Extremely quick service. Definitely will be back

  steve L
7 years ago
Friendly local garage. Owner is always friendly and willing to answer any questions you have. Not once did i feel like i was a bother like other places i been to.

  ladonna couch
6 years ago
Always a great experience. Service and pricing is wonderful. Thank you for taking care of our trucks and family safety.

  Walter Everly
6 months ago
Great services fair prices.

  Michael Sheridan
6 years ago
T.J. at Mr. Smiths garage is a fair & honest mechanic.He & his team there are awesome , i take both of my vehicles there!

  Saiyan Cthulhu Ent
2 years ago
Fantastic! Very friendly and got the work done fast and good prices.

  Mark Fleis
3 years ago
Good service, cranked lug nut's too tight, went to put new rotors on the next day and one sheared off. No follow through on fixing

  Jennifer Provenzano
4 years ago
Fair, affordable and does great work. I will definitely use them again. Very nice to deal with.

  Richard Stang
2 years ago
As always, great work, fair price and quick. I would recommend to everyone!

  Devin Smith
a year ago
Used their contact us for an appointment tool weeks ago, never heard back from them.

  Johan Geist
2 years ago
Had a great experience. Very professional. I couldn t be happier. Thank you

  Kevin Lewis
2 years ago
TJ provides great a service fir your car or truck!