Fair & Square Automotive Group

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Rachael Hambalko
2 weeks ago
Andrew runs a great dealership. His cars are great and he is very helpful and sweet. I bought a used suburban from here and everything was handled fast and easy. Great with communication and he s very honest. When I picked up my new truck it was nicely detailed and had a full tank. I totally recommend buying from here!! Great people, great deals, great business. :)

  Dianne Dileo
4 months ago
Just got a car from them today through Albert and Andrew. They are both wonderful to deal with. They both have been very helpful and friendly to deal with. They re very easy to talk to and made the whole experience in getting a loan very smoothly. Awesome customer service. Two nice guy s

  Jaden Gorman
2 weeks ago
Great dealer, very organized and guy is down to earth and honest. No dealer fees and they are as honest as it gets. Very fair pricing too.

  Donna Hepworth
2 months ago
Awesome people there. Andrew and Al took absolute best care of me. Worked miracle with my loans. Had the perfect car for me a 2008 Toyota prius.new hybrid batteries installed... will b using them as my mechanic in the future...highly recommended. Got me my ride in one day.

  Ryan Janesko
3 weeks ago
I didn t think it was possible to get financing considering I m building my credit back. Andrew got it done with only a 2k down payment. I was able to walk out with a trusted vehicle. I highly recommend!

  Lachelle Brewster
3 weeks ago
Had a wonderful experience considering I gave them a run for their money! Got approved and In a truck with little to no hassle. Love their hospitality and customer service! They went above and beyond to help me.

  Allison Kirby
2 months ago
Worked with Andrew and Albert.Great people to buy from. Total professionalism and helpful. Answered all questions throughly.Would definitely recommend Fair Square to anyone who is looking for a good used car !! Go see them !!

  Kathy Ito
2 weeks ago
I love the 12 Chevy Malibu . I would definitely buy my next vehicle here. Great cars and fair pricing. Definitely come here and check them out.

  Dorothea S.
a year ago
My husband, Tom, and I just purchased a car from Fair and Square and WOW were are SO IMPRESSED with the care we received from Andrew and Albert! When we arrived there we let them know about our bad credit and that our other car was totaled in an accident and that we thought we had coverage, but didn t, so we needed to rent a car for two months. It was getting so costly and we were really not sure if we would get an approval from any bank. Andrew worked so hard to find a bank that would work with us and Albert helped us gather the information necessary to obtain the car. They also gave us deals just because we live in the community! They are such an asset to Islip Terrace and the surrounding neighborhoods! Everything went so smoothly!! We HIGHLY recommend Fair and Square! Please go check them out ASAP! They deserve a five star rating!

  Emily Carmelitano
2 months ago
I got a used car from Andrew, it was great because I didn't have great credit and he was able to get me a car loan. It was quick and efficient. Other than that it has been a nightmare. The car has had nothing but issues. They make their cars look nice but do not fully or adequately check their cars before selling. I had nothing but issues with the car and was lied to many times. First day of having it check engine came on, the O2 sensor had to be replaced. They replaced it no problem (even though they definitely cleared the code for the sensor hoping it wouldn't come back on too soon but it did). Then 2 days after that of driving. The torque sensor went. My steering locked up and I almost got into an accident. They wanted me to pay to have this replaced, I refused because I didn t even drive the car more than 100 miles since buying it. This was an on going issue that they maybe did not know about. Fine. Then my car is making loud clunking noise like the strut is bad. Get it checked by my mechanic who I trust and the strut mount was broken, the car shouldn't have been inspected (which they did for me when purchased). I understand I bought a used car but to not even drive it for a week and have all these issues is absolutely ridiculous. I brought it back there after finding out about the strut and they were going to fix it after I said I would report them for illegal inspection. Then proceeded to lie to me saying the strut mount was not broken. I have taken it to 2 shops since and all say it is broken and should not have left their lot like this. I was lied to and manipulated. Very very upsetting. This was not from MY ware and tare nor was it disclosed to me during purchase. Also the breaks JUSTTTT passed inspection by like 2%. The car needs at least 2,000$ of work. Do not buy a car from them!!!!!! This caused manyyyy issues for me. Could not drive for work and had to miss work many times over the course of this after spending 7,000 plus on a car. This was all in a 2 weeks span. They do not sell quality cars! I have filed a report with DMV with proof this car was inspected illegally and none of this was disclosed.

  evan kozak
a year ago
Just got my first car from them for a great deal and I have 0 complaints. Andrew is a super nice and down to earth guy who helped me find the right car and not only did he answer all of my questions, but also took the time to teach me some stuff. Fair and Square made getting my first car quick, fun, and simple, and they got a great selection of quality used cars.

  Cyprian Chic
a year ago
Looking for a car for my daughter and was recommended to go to Fair & Square. Met with Andrew who was very helpful finding a couple of vehicles within budget. Test drove them and ended up purchasing the Jeep Compass. Andrew made it so easy and the transaction process was completed in a couple of days. Definitely would recommend coming here if you need a vehicle.

  Ajah Motley
3 weeks ago
I have no credit or anything but Andrew and Al made sure I got a car. Fast and efficient service ,trustworthy also very fair prices.

  Casey Krebs
2 years ago
Just completed the purchase of a 2017 Chevy Cruze from Andrew at Fair & Square Automotive Group. I came here after witnessing a great experience my brother had here. Fair & Square does not do the brand justice. Andrew was extremely easy to work with, timely, and had me driving my new car in less than 2 days. As a consumer less savvy than most, Andrew had all the answers to my questions with unlimited patients. Andrew has a nice selection on the lot but made my choice more simple than I imagined it would be. Highly recommend for great vehicles and smoother transactions!!!

  Michael Krebs
2 years ago
I ve known Andrew since high school and he s always been an honest and hardworking guy. For my first car purchase, I was very excited and pleased to be working him, knowing he always provides an amazing deal and awesome cars. Every step of the process was quick and easy, and the car is beautiful and runs smooth. I know I m going to be using this car for a long time, as promised! I would recommend Andrew for ANYONE looking for a great and affordable vehicle. I m excited to be back on road with this car and I ll continue to return for business in the future.

  Alex Herrera
4 months ago
If you need a quality used car at a fair price then see Andrew yesterday! Tell him Batman sent you! He'll treat you like family!!!

  Lilly Figueroa
9 months ago
I was looking for a car and I came across Fair and Square Automotive Group and was so impressed! They have a very good selection of cars and the prices are extremely reasonable, and Andrew and Grandpa Al were very helpful. I didn t think I would get my car loan approved and Andrew went above and beyond and made it happen! He was very kind and caring to work with! I absolutely love my car and I highly recommend them to everyone!

  Frank Petrella
a year ago
Andrew was polite,friendly and never pressured us through our interactions. He listened to what we wanted and worked with what our budget was. He answered all questions and gave us options. I would definitely recommend dealing with Andrew.

  Joseph Barclay
6 months ago
Had an amazing experience at Fair & Square Automotive Group. Would recommend them to anyone. Really made me feel like family throughout the entire process. They accept crypto payments as well! Has to be the first on the island!

  Melinda George
9 months ago
My son just purchased his first car with Andrew today! Andrew was honest, professional, and very knowledgeable. The whole process took one day. They even gave him a full tank of gas! Nice touch. We will definitely purchase future vehicles at Fair & Square.

  Jessica Burke
8 months ago
Had a great experience at this place! Prices are very fair. Andrew and Al were great to work with and made the whole process comfortable and as little stress as possible for me and my husband. We were in a pinch to get a vehicle asap and we had our truck on the road within 24 hours. We will definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a car in the future

  Chris VanBuskirk
10 months ago
Al & Andrew went above and beyond to make the entire car buying experience stress free. I was expecting the worst & got the best. Came in with my old car, advised me as far as credit & the best deals, trade in, discounts applied, registered, cleaned & off I went. What a relief !I will return for myself & any family member that needs a car.Thanks again guysChris

  Josh Rodriguez
9 months ago
Just purchased a nice truck from Fair & Square and Andrew & Albert were awesome. They made they process quick and easy. Would definitely recommend this place to anyone. Buying a car is never easy but these guys are honest and made the process smooth.

  louinete maitre
11 months ago
My experience here was 10/10. They made it so easy for me to get a car, even through the difficult conversations with companies, my father and I were still able to see the car and receive the car 2 days later. Andrew, one of the workers, was able to get us approved in under 30 minutes and made sure we didn t leave without the car, their vehicles are mostly under 10k, Grandpa Ale was able to verse my dad with his contradictions, and they make you feel at home. You re allowed to sit back and relax, they offer you food and drinks, and Steve (another worker) was working back and forth diligently but still made time to give me an amazing SpongeBob impression. Overall, I would recommend people to come here for a car they would like to buy if they are looking for affordable, and negotiable prices.

  Jeritt Lewis
10 months ago
It s was a distinguished privilege to acquire a vehicle from Fair and Square. From the initial introduction Albert greeted me at the door with courtesy and kindness. Andrew exceeded my expectations by adjusting his hours to accommodate my hectic schedule. Upon our conversation I was educated and informed on great options to meet my needs. The sales process was seamless. I really encourage anyone looking to purchase a vehicle consider Fair and Square today!

  Linessa Leftenant
11 months ago
Fair & Sqaure is a great place to buy a car or even finance a car.My boyfriend and I came here looking for a truck and found exactly what we wanted. The process was quick.Andrew and Albert are the best, so helpful, friendly and communicative!I most definitely recommend coming here to get a car or truck!Also this is our first car off a lot and they made it an amazing experience!!When it s time for a new truck I m definitely coming back here!!!!!

  Vanessa Lopez
11 months ago
Absolute best experience I ve ever had buying a car. Albert and Andrew put me at ease through the entire process; truly white glove service. If you re looking for a great, reliable used car- search no more!! Stop at Fair & Square and get all of your car needs met with complete and total peace of mind!

  Kash Jr
3 weeks ago
They real good they make it happen got my car in a week and they got excellent service

  Michele Perez
7 months ago
Hello to anyone reading this message!We just bought a vehicle at this very nice dealer where we have being treated with respect, professionalism and like a family member. Andrew thank you for going far and beyond for us!

  raymond marter
6 months ago
Very happy, it s was a pleasure dealing with the guys! Hopefully I won t back back until my next toy! Second car from these guys they re the best!