Maguire Toyota of Grand Island

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Joanne Galley
a month ago
I had an amazing experience purchasing my Toyota Tacoma! Xavier Matthews was incredibly personable and knowledgeable. He reviewed the flip book and all the benefits of buying from Maguire. He helped me work within my budget and make my truck buying experience completely stress free! I highly recommend purchasing your next vehicle from any of the Maguire dealerships.

  Jake Eberth
2 months ago
My experience at Maguire was nothing short of excellent! The car was priced very competitively, adjusted appropriately according to the market at the time, and was sold to me without any sense of pressure at all. Dylan and Ai were great at putting together an awesome deal and were so accommodating. Plus, the hot chocolate while I waited was delicious :) I'll continue to recommend this dealership to others!

  Michael Hoerbelt
2 months ago
I traded in my 21 Prius Prime here for a brand new 24 Prius Prime, and chose them over the other 2 dealerships I had in mind for the area: West Herr and Basil. The best reason I went with MacGuire was their ability to listen to what I wanted and work with me on that timeline. Dylan was my sales person and was very patient, kind, and knowledgeable about the vehicle and ways I could finance the vehicle. I ended up financing through a credit union in far away from Grand Island.The sales manager Ai there was also very kind and informative about what options I had to cover my new car, what different options were available to finance the car, etc.I LOVE my new car, the Stardust Crusader. It sure has a lot of quirks, mainly between the digital key app and the manual unlocking with my hand. I m still learning the system, and I m confident I ll find out all the little cool things about it along the way. My last Prius had a locking problem as well where it d lock me out of the driver side sometimes.This Prime is very futuristic and has the double sun glass roof. I don t think I ll get any closer to a spaceship until 2030, when I believe electric cars will dominate the market. Until then, I hope to finish out this decade with this car. It is SUPER sexy, fast, and more efficient than the 21 that I had.

  kevin attwood
a week ago
Dylan and the staff were friendly and outstanding. Really appreciate all the effort and help they gave us to get into a new vehicle. We love it and look forward to working together with them soon for a second time. Traded out of a 2015 Mitsubishi outlander in the new Toyota Corolla cross. Love it

  Charles Galante
2 months ago
I cannot express enough gratitude for the outstanding service we received from Cody at Maguire Dealership when assisting my sister in purchasing a vehicle. From the moment we walked in, Cody's professionalism and genuine enthusiasm for helping us find the perfect car were truly remarkable.Cody took the time to understand my sister's preferences and budget constraints, ensuring a tailored approach to the entire car-buying process. His extensive knowledge of the available vehicles, coupled with a patient and friendly demeanor, made the experience not only smooth but also enjoyable.What truly set Cody apart was his commitment to ensuring my sister felt confident and well-informed throughout the entire journey. He explained every detail, from the vehicle's features to the financing options, with clarity and expertise. Cody's dedication to customer satisfaction was evident in the personalized attention he provided, making the entire process a breeze.As someone assisting a family member, I couldn't have asked for a better ally than Cody. His genuine interest in ensuring my sister's needs were met went above and beyond our expectations. If you're in search of a car sales professional who combines expertise with a personal touch, Cody at Maguire Dealership is the one to trust.Thank you, Cody, for making my sister's car-buying experience not only successful but also enjoyable. Your exceptional service has left a lasting impression, and we wholeheartedly recommend you to anyone in need of a dedicated and knowledgeable car salesperson.

  Daryle Macro
4 months ago
It was a pleasure working with Dylan Guzenski and the entire staff at Maguire Toyota of Grand Island. It was one of the easiest car buying experiences I ve had. Thank you for your kind service. We love our new car.

  Andrea Walters
a month ago
I've had nothing but great experiences at this dealership. We have another Toyota dealer that is closer to home, but we make the drive to Maguire because of Sarah. Over the years, she has been a terrific sales representative. She's knowledgeable about the vehicles, doesn't pressure you into buying, is helpful with any issues that might arise, and keeps in touch throughout the leasing period. She's truly one of a kind and it's people like her that keeps me coming back to do business with Maguire Toyota. Thanks Sarah!

  Amy Minnick
a week ago
Scheduled my Tundra for recall work for Feb. 19th. Dropped the truck off and was later told they did not have the parts necessary to perform the recall. Told that parts would take 3 weeks to come in and we would have to bring the truck back. We are now in mid April. I called a week ago to request a status update and have not received a call back. In the meantime, a 5th recall has been issued for the truck.Otherwise, Christian, the service tech was very sympathetic and sorry that we were allowed to schedule service online without the parts being in stock for the repair.

  Matt Dickerson
5 months ago
Trevon Hopkins is the man and hooked it up on my new truck under sticker with great value on my trade. Couldn t recommend the dealer any more highly and I truly believe the whole staff did everything in their power to make sure I left a happy customer. Take a look at their inventory if you re shopping for a new Toyota!

  Jessie Galante
2 months ago
I had the most enlightening customer service with Cody Herman at Maguire Dealership. Cody guaranteed me that he would take care of me in making sure my needs where met to satisfy my budget concerns on a new 2024 vehicle. He was patient, professional and made sure I understood everything from finances to all the new modern features of my new vehicle. Cody s personal touch made a big impact on my driving away feeling like I was in good safe hands. Thank you Cody!

  Kirsten Yates-Konzen
2 months ago
Very pleased with Maguire Toyota of Grand Island. Dylan, in particular, was very helpful, answering all our questions (we had many as we were driving to Grand Island from out of state to purchase a Prius Prime.) He kept us informed and he anticipated issues with out of state insurance; his assistance streamlined our purchase process. Dylan was also very knowledgeable about the vehicle itself and provided clear instructions which got us on the road and home safely. He has also been willing to answer additional questions weeks after purchase. We wish we lived closer. We'd work with Dylan and Maguire all the time!

  Bruce Hickey
2 weeks ago
The best car buying experience that I've had - a perfect transaction. Salesperson Dylan and manager A. I. were excellent in all respects. I have already recommended them to three friends.

  Dan Sims
2 months ago
Had a good experience, and I don't especially like looking for a new vehicle. Y0ur dealership was no nonsense, the deal was handled very quickly and professionally, happy I made my purchase with you. My wife just purchased a new Toyota van a couple weeks ago. We're pleased with the service.

  Nina Paulsen
a week ago
We just worked with Cody. Always a pleasure to work with somebody who does what they say they are going to do when they said they were going to do it.Our buying experience was quick and pleasant and we highly recommend Cody.Casey and Nina

  Vincent Musolino
a week ago
A great car dealership. They are some of the most accommodating and honest people I ve worked with in the car industry. I highly recommend them, and its service department. Brianne and Ai, Thank You!

  Melissa Qualey
2 months ago
Xavier was easy to work with and provided great customer service! Any time I had to wait he offered water and kept me updated throughout the process. I went in considering buying used but we were able to get to a place where I was able to purchase new. Thanks Xavier! Go Bandits!

  Jordan Vaccaro
a month ago
Just recently bought a used BMW from Maguire Toyota and had a great experience. The salesman s name was Xavier and he was totally upfront and honest from the minute I first spoke with him and delivered on every thing he said. Love the car and it was a pleasure dealing with Xavier and Maguire Toyota.

  Richard Scaduto
2 months ago
I had an excellent experience at this dealership. I put a deposit down on a vehicle that was slated for delivery in about 6 weeks. No surprise fees or issues when the car came in. The sales person Sarah was very kind and helpful.

  Todd Walters
a month ago
Sarah is 1 of a kind sales rep. She has helped me and my wife with several leases. Great asset to this dealership. Also you can never forget AI who comes in clutch on the deals.

  Theresa M
5 months ago
I wish I could do two separate reviews because the service manager Justin is exceptional and I will continue to tell everyone I know how great he is ! He is a 5 star man. Just to cut out a long story of my buying process I m just gonna go straight to who made it all worth it and talk about Justin. He runs a really nice team and his knowledge in the industry is nothing short of epic! He keeps to his word and has got time management down! How many places have you gone where your just waiting and waiting like did they forget about me ?? He will explain step by step and make you feel like a long time friend or even family member. Can t get better than that. Every time I work with him my car is done right on time. If something is needed he goes above and beyond. Thank you Justin and Maguire for hiring such an asset

  Yasina Semy
2 months ago
We have been to Maguire every time we need a new car and they never disappoint us. The sales manager is awesome and knows exactly what we need. We are currently purchasing our 3rd Toyota from Maguire and they t99k care of us every time. Dylan took care of everything for us and made the process very easy. We love Macguire Toyota!

  Francis Bax
2 months ago
Maguire Toyota of Grand IslandFeb 3, 2024francis.baxMy wife and I are regular customers at this location on Grand Island and have referred several of our friends to purchase cars there. The only word I have to say is AWESOME! We've never been disappointed with staff or with the vehicles we've purchased there and always have been pleased and happy with the service! We've always worked closely with Alan and Xavier as well as Ai. Don't worry, we'll be back, might be a while since both my wife and I bought new vehicles, but in the meantime, we're going to bring friends and associates over when they are looking at buying new cars!!

  Domonique Jackson
2 months ago
Wow.. Where do I even begin? I currently reside in Georgia and began actively searching for a used Chevrolet Bolt EV in Georgia Nov 2023. After months of dealing with $10,000 dealership markups, negotiations after negotiations, headaches, frustration, and tears, I began looking out of state. I came across a Chevrolet Bolt EUV in Florida - bought a one-way ticket to purchase the vehicle and drive it back to Georgia, only for the Florida dealership to increase the price once I arrived - which resulted in me having to fly back home with no car.My dad came across a Chevrolet Bolt EUV that had all of the bells and whistles: leather seats, Bose audio, supercruise, moonroof, etc. The caveat, however, was the vehicle was in New York and by that time I was tired of dealing with salesmen, knew the price listed would be $10k more out the door, and didn t want the hassle of purchasing out of state. To our surprise, Maguire Toyota of Grand Island proved us wrong!My dad spoke with Xavier W. who not only gave us clear, detailed pricing, the out-the-door price wasn t marked up and he told us every step of the way what to expect throughout the buying process, specifically being out-of-state customers. This is my first vehicle purchase and he made me feel at ease the entire time - something I haven t felt the last four months with other dealers. Xavier W. sent over clear videos and pictures of the vehicle before purchase, discussed warranty information with us, and informed me on the financing process being that my banking institution was in Georgia.It doesn t stop there! Xavier W. also referred me to a reputable transportation company to get the vehicle towed from New York to Georgia and provided me with an update once the towing company arrived at the dealership. Even after the transaction was made and the car left the dealership lot, Xavier W. still reached out to ensure that I had received the vehicle in Georgia. His communication throughout the entire process was superb. There are times in Georgia were I have felt overlooked or look down upon by salesmen. However, this was no issue for Xavier W. He was professional, treated me with respect, and was consistent and prompt when communicating via email/text.THIS IS MY FIRST VEHICLE PURCHASE AND I MADE THE TRANSACTION SIGHT UNSEEN! Once the vehicle was in my possession, it arrived exactly as pictured. Getting behind the wheel to take it for a spin for the first time after purchasing made all the months of headache worthwhile. Maguire Toyota of Grand Island is the place to purchase your vehicle no matter where you are in the United States! The professionalism, communication, and compassion is truly unmatched.

  S Semy
2 months ago
This is the best dealership in WNY I ve seen so far with regard to their attitude and how they treat their customers. Truly the best service out there. A.I , the sales manager, and Dylan the sales rep have always helped us and gave us a deal we could not resist.

  Noa Gim
2 months ago
Purchased a vehicle here from an associate named Bri. Communicated w her for a few weeks over the phone and emails. Couldn t ask for a better car buying experience. She also handled the finances which was a big surprise. I would definitely go back to her if I were to buy another one. Find Bri if you want a straightforward no game buying experience.

  ripudaman dixit
5 months ago
I wholeheartedly endorse this dealership, even after their transition from Fuccillo to Maguire. The staff here exudes honesty, providing transparent advice without hidden costs, a rarity among dealers in this area. My delightful experience spanning eight years speaks volumes. Special mention to the exceptional finance manager AI and their stellar service team.Best wishes to Maguire Toyota!

  Nick Adams
2 months ago
Just stepping in the door felt like a good group of people would be helping me. Bri was one of the most informed and kind cars sales women I know. I bother her with all my detailed questions and she honestly answered them all. Her interest with my car felt great and personal. Because of all she did I bought the car. As well as go back for all car needs with them! Thank you Bri!! you rock!!!!

  Henry Kaack
a month ago
Great place, great deals, Ai and Allan awesome and no better vehicle than a Toyota

  Donna Backshall
4 months ago
INSIDER TIP: If you have an appointment for service, their policy is to leave your car for last if you're not physically waiting. You have to specifically request to have your scheduled appointment time honored. I learned that the hard way today.Their website lets you think you can schedule service, but it's broken. When you give up and just call, they say they know it doesn't work, but no one's doing anything about it.Even if you're just getting a regular maintenance service, they'll try to upsell you on unnecessary things for outrageous prices. Case in point: I just replaced my cabin filter myself for $10, yet while wrapping up my service appointment, it was "recommended" to have them change it out for $70 today, among other things I already know I don't need. When I inquired what they saw to push such a recommendation, as I know it's new and clean, they had no answer. Forced to read from a shady script.I actually felt like a valued customer when it was Fuccillo. Now I just feel disappointed.

  sue brown
a month ago
Ai and Xavier worked there hardest . To make sure I got the car I wanted . It says a lot when Ai came in on his day off . Just so he could help make sure every went smooth ,I have been coming to this dealership since 2006 and will continue to.