Cassadaga Shur Fine

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Marilyn Dragon
a month ago
New owners are amazing. If you haven't experienced their Indian food buffet, it's a must !! Friend them up on Facebook to get their menus and offerings. So glad to have them here to give is such delicious food choices and some diversity. Prices are fair as well.

  sarah conley
3 months ago
Nearly all of the machines are posted as Out of Order but the ones that are not still don't work. Dryers eat your money but don't turn on, washers DO NOT in fact get anything clean, just wet. This is not my first time here and it's actually gotten worse. Just Go to Mayville or Dunkirk.

  Bri Harroun
7 months ago
Used to be a great business it s empty inside hardly any people. I spent $50 on pizza and wings and the food was cold and I didn t get my change back that s okay keep my .26 cents I think you need it more than me! All food is really outdated and it s overall depressing inside and I will not be going in there again oh and they shut down all the gas pumps it s like they really don t want any customers.

  Jay Hough
a year ago
Great small town store. Sure there is a bad fruit or vegetable on the shelf every now and again, but I feel like the owners are doing the best they can.The deli is fantastic, stuffed crust pizza is awesome!Went in Monday looking for an Ethernet cable and they dont sell them, but the owner offered me a spare he had in his office. great people.They have our business in the future!

  Rajvinder Singh
6 months ago
Under new management! Neat and clean store with great customer service! Jason at the front is fantastic!

  Jerry Smith
a year ago
I used to visit here monthly. Place used to be amazing. Now, what the heck? Place looks like a disaster. New freezers. Barely built. Stopped in meat. 90% of everything was outdated. Even saw multiple shelves advertising outdated product marked down. I expected days. Not months!!!! It's September. One was March.Pizza was ok. Used to be the bomb. This will be my last stop.

  John M
a year ago
Once the place of amazing sub sandwiches, that time has passed I guess. They used to be loaded with meats and cheese and all the trimmings, but in the last year their sub sandwiches have become sub-standard. Smaller, less filling, poorer quality. The prices went up (which we all expect), but the quality also went down. I won t be purchasing from them any more. The Shute Fine in Belfast NY still makes a rockin Sub!!!

  tonya ham
7 years ago
This store is great. It has everything in one store. You can get subs, pizza, deli meat, fresh chicken breast. As well as all your canned goods, even get your keys made and tools and many hardware items with your milk. Everyone that works there is so friendly and helpful. LOVE it.

  Dukhant Multani
6 months ago
New management has uplifted the store and continues the uplift to better serve the community

  Bonnie Fewtrell
5 years ago
Everyone that works at this store is friendly and willing to help. The deli is wonderful and has the best breakfast sandwiches ever because they actually make them while you're standing there. The coffee is very good. Because the store is in a rural-ish location it's talks everything from food items To Nuts and Bolts. Great store.

  Outdoor Nut
4 years ago
We stopped for lunch while snowmobiling, and they had the best soup and sandwich combo around. They have a nice cafe inside the store, where your meal is served to you hot and fresh. The gas pumps have ethanol free gas available also. Right on the trails so you can ride to the store.

  Mary Ruge
4 years ago
This is a great supermarket, they have everything from food to hardware as well as a gas station! Friendly staff too! Really good bakery items as well! I discovered this store back in the 80's because we had a seasonal campsite at Woodside Campground, which is less than a 10 minute drive to Shur fine.

  Rich Koenig
2 years ago
A few months ago I had a 20 pound propane tank filled at SureFine. The employee overfilled the tank. A full tank should weigh 37 pounds. Mine weighed over 41 pounds. Over one gallon too much propane. When I connected the tank to my grill it acted like the regulator had failed so I purchased a new one and replaced it. I had no idea that the tank was overfilled. The new regulator acted just like the old one, freezing up and spewing propane. I am going to try to bleed off the excess by opening the bleeder screw on the side of the valve.

  Sandy Green
4 years ago
Not impressed. Spent over $70 in pizza and wings and got 1 small container of dressing, asked for another one and it was going to cost me 2 bucks for a little 2 oz. Container...went to dollar general and got a whole bottle! If this store loses business it is there own fault

  jacob toy
2 years ago
I recently purchased a gallon of OJ from shurefine and got home to find that it was a month expired! I have also, on multiple occasions, noticed produce that had mold or were over ripped to the point of being wrinkly and squishy. I have politely talked to the owners that their stock men might not be doing their jobs to the best of their abilities, and there hasn t been any real changes from what I ve seen.

  Tina Sabat
4 years ago
A small store but it provides a little of everything. From food to housewares to hardware. They have an excellant deli serving hot and cold subs , salads , lunchmeat, pizza and more. As well there is a generous seating area. I would highly recommend Cassadaga Shur Fine.

  Kelley Krum Kumro
5 years ago
This store not only has all your needs but they have top grade meat deals and the best part is they have takeout and delivery and their food is amazing! Homemade, fresh food and a deli section with all kinds of things !

  Daniel L Wysocki
6 years ago
The best Meat in the County,Awesome Deli,and owners and employees that will bend over to make you happy! Its really got anything you may need,and I am allways happy with the service.Its locally owned and operated which is a rarity this day and age.

  Angel Louie Ruiz-Leone
10 months ago
Sure find grocery store in Cassadaga was owned by a different family before good atmosphere you had people working there now is bought over by a different family you walk in there there are no employees everything's cameras date at the same thing at caves they fired everybody and they put cameras up so they can run it with family owned only you walking to Sure finding Cassadaga the father or the owner there kind of rude not really polite doesn't say much doesn't even say hello the wife she's out going always talking and talking and then they start talking in their native tongue and then they start looking at you and you don't know what they're saying is it right that you're trying not to discriminate against people but they look at you like you're no good I don't like walking into that store and sure finding Cassadaga anymore because of that reason you're not a person you're a number give me your money and get the hell out caves Deli and Forestville happened the same way taking over by a new family everybody got fired and they put cameras up I went in there a couple days ago to get some lottery tickets the young man who was there on the phone didn't even look at me didn't even acknowledge me took my money gave me my tickets and walked away it's hard to treat people the right way when they treat you in a different way I hope things can change for both of these stores thank you for your time

  knightnrmer
2 years ago
I was there today at 2:00 . I remember what this store was 4 years ago and it is a shame on what it is now . The store used to be non stop busy but now there was only 2 other shoppers in the store . No cashiers was my 1st red flag . High prices made me pick things up and put them back down . I won't be back and feel sorry for the community . The 5 star reviews are from the owners and or relatives . Disgraceful .... not worth one star .

  Shawn Wilson
5 years ago
Shelves are getting barer and barer, and prices are still too high. There were no mushrooms, no 5 for 20 mashed, veggies were freezer burnt again. A lot of reduced meat which I don't like to buy. No mixture of different pre sliced cheeses , idk. Im not impressed.

  david Disaverio
5 years ago
I put in a fairly large order of 3 party pizza packs , the order was ready on time all the food was done just like I had asked for it to be done everything was perfect and everyone was very helpful and polite , I will be ordering more often from Cassadaga sure fine !!! :)

  Maria Steckman
5 years ago
Amazing prices for a small town store. They even have an area to sit and eat by their deli. The subs are fantastic. The people are great.

  Tina Sabat
6 years ago
For a little store,they have a good selection of items. The deli is excellent. No matter if it be a sub,lunchmeat or pizza everything is fresh and delicious.

  Peter Spiegel
5 years ago
Enjoyed a nice deli lunch located inside the small grocery store. The prices were good, food fantastic and the small dining area very comfortable.

  Fadl Alnami
2 years ago
Great customer service and the new owners seem friendlier. He also gave me his personal number in case i need to reach out immediatelyThanks Bobby

  Andy Hamrick
a year ago
Rating not low enough website says your open till 9:00 and we couldn't do our laundry, and not very friendly people there thanks for wasting our gas money to come there .Bad management.

  Susan Bradigan
5 years ago
Great fast food,a diner,and breakfast pizza that's to die for. Groceries set up nice,even a hardware store,laundromat, gas station. And a bank on the side.

  Margaret Herrick
5 years ago
Great little town grocery. They also serve food. Every time I went found everything I needed, and food was really pretty good.

  Jay Johnson
4 years ago
Nice little store for the essentials and a good deli. Other items you would not see in other stores, but make perfect sense in a rural area.