Schwartz & Nagle Tires, Inc.

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Sophie Pastore
a week ago
I ve been getting my oil changed here since I moved to the area and have had a great experience every time! They don t try to upsell you on things you don t need. I also got my tires replaced here and felt the price was very fair. All of their work is easy to schedule and has a quick turnaround.

  Ron M
4 months ago
Schwartz & Nagel is our go to automotive repair shop. We've been going there for years. They are knowledgeable and trustworthy. We've consistently been pleased with their service and would not hesitate to recommend them.

  Sam Mann
a month ago
Took my Toyota Highlander here for brake's they drove it and inspected them my brakes were actually in good condition and did not need to be replaced .I appreciate honesty I will be using you from now on thanks To Matt!!! you guy's are the best!!!

  Scott Richard
3 weeks ago
So happy to have found mechanics that you can really trust! Many mechanics can fix your car, but not all are fair and honest! Schwartz and Nagle are just that! I highly recommend the again and again!

  Kenneth Kelly Jr
7 months ago
This is my third visit in three years, and all have been great experiences! Quality of service and the work done is top notch and I have not had any problems whatsoever. My experiences with Matt and his Dad Jerry, and the other staff I have had interaction with have been a pleasure. Waiting area is comfortable and very clean (the coffee is pretty darn good too!). Prices are very reasonable, and you won't find a better place to go when you need tires or related repair work. 5 Stars all the way around! I'll be back!

  Amy King
6 months ago
I work in Highland Park, and my entire office referred Schwartz & Nagle to me when I asked about repairs for my car. The past couple of auto mechanics I had used were awful and pricey so I lost faith in them! S&N was able to take my car in right away and diagnose the issues, explain them and quote $ to me, and then fixed them ASAP! Like within a couple of hours! And the prices were unbelievably lower than other places. I now have a renewed faith in auto mechanics (well, as long as they are only from Schwartz & Nagle!) Thanks to Matt and his staff! Great job!

  Hesria Rantung
4 months ago
Tesla Tesla Tesla! What a wonderful service! Replaced 4 brand new tires and a new TPMS on a 2021 Tesla Model Y (Bluetooth version) they have all the Pucs that are needed with every Tesla to be lifted. To top it all best prices for tires and very competitive ask for Matt

  C Birkenhauer
2 years ago
I could not place my 1998 Lexus GS 300 in better hands than Matt and his crew. My Oakhurst Lexus dealer failed me and was both insulting as to why I wanted to repair my beloved car and strongly suggested I give up on repairs.I could not find a better place to care for my car than Schwartz and Nagel. Thank you for your outstanding service! They arranged for towing to their place and even drove my car back to my place after the repairs.

  Marjan Atienza
2 months ago
Quick service and prices are really good. Discount for Rutgers staff/students. Recommending this to my colleagues.

  Nikki Nuna
10 months ago
John and Matt highly recommended. Towed in and needed radiator hoses repaired temperature gaskets. Identified the issue and repaired. Reliable trustworthy services. Definitely will return. Thank you again.

  Kathy O'Leary
11 months ago
Vince Gabriel took care of my old clunkers 50+years ago at Gabriel tire center, then Vince retired and his son Jerry and his great crew always kept me on the road for many years after that.Now Matthew Gabriel, Jerry's son, and his crew do the same top job for me..John on the front desk has helped keep me going for many years, and is a really great guy.Tires I would go with the Coopers or Michelin.Dennis

  Zeshan Ansari
9 months ago
Went to them for a flat tire. Tim hooked me up with a great deal on a replacement tire with labor included. Great service, honest, genuine folks. Highly recommended!

  Julie Castellano
a year ago
Thank you, Matt and crew, for helping me assess and solve the issue of my persistent tire leak! Matt was transparent in communicating the real problem and explained what the previous tire mechanic did wrong (only two days before for the same problem). He explained why a simple tire plug or patch would not work and made me feel like my safety was a priority for him. Even though I had to shell out to pay for new tires in the end (due to natural wear and tire in addition to leak), I felt comfortable doing so because I knew I wasn't getting ripped off! Would recommend and visit again!

  Barbara Ross
2 years ago
my family has been coming here for many years, and although the owners have changed, the high quality of the service and customer support are unchanged. From the smallest, most easily fixed repair to the more involved work, the folks at Schwartz and Nagle are the best. Honest, realistic, friendly and knowledgeable. You can't go wrong!

  Mary Callahan
4 years ago
I've brought my car there 3 times in the past six months all for different problems and each time I was thrilled with the service I received. They are honest and reasonable, and the issues were completely fixed. One of the times they even referred me back to the dealer for something that was still under warranty. They could have easily fixed it themselves and charged me for it. I know you'll be pleased when you bring your car here. We've been customers for well over 10 years.

  ali jubair
a year ago
I went for an oil change since they were listed as service partners for Uber Drivers through Car Advice. First of all they used the wrong oil (0W-20) instead 0W-16 which was clearly mentioned on the engine. They also didnt completely close the Underground Engine cover which ended up breaking later. I went to the dealership and discussed both issues but they were extremely rude and said that booklet has 0w-20 which was never mentioned as the recommended oil on my engine and dealership also used 0w-16. They also refused to take any liability for the broken underground cover. Avoid this workshop as much as possible. Simply rude and terrible service

  Lois Johnson
2 years ago
I have been going to this shop since 1997. They guarantee their work (a real plus). If there is a fault in any previous part they have installed or repaired, there is no charge. Also, they partner with great towing companies. If you need a tow, just call Schwartz & Nagle and they will arrange it for you. They run a great shop. Definitely recommend them for all your auto needs.

  Kerstin Howarth
3 years ago
I've been having my cars serviced here for years. As many reviewers have said, they are honest, friendly, fair, and competent. What I like the most is that when I have a problem, they explain it well, and work with me to find any cost effective alternatives if there are any. I also get my tires here:). I really appreciate Rick's customer service approach. He has set up a very nice waiting room with a TV that you can mute or change. He supports the local artists by hanging their work in the waiting room, which is a nice touch. You will not be disappointed when you bring your cars here.

  vero w
a year ago
The crew at Schwartz and Nagle are always efficient at fixing any issue I bring in with my car. They are also great at reminding me about upcoming service or things I might want to consider fixing in the future. They ve always gone out of their way to answer my questions too. Highly recommend this friendly shop.

  Dara G
6 years ago
I had such a great experience with these guys! My AC compressor locked up and they offered me not only a great price, but excellent service as well. The work was also done within a few hours of me dropping it off. I paid the price I wanted, had a great conversation when I picked up my car, and I am staying cool all summer :) Thanks so much!I have to add on to my previous review! I had another amazing experience here! Honest, polite, efficient and reassuring. My Honda dealership mislead me and the guys at S&N made sure I left happy and safe. I cannot thank you enough for all your hard work and dedication.If you live in Middlesex county, it is worth the trip. LOVE THESE GUYS!!

  Rocco G Fierro
6 months ago
Matt prevented catastrophic engine failure by quick and accurate diagnosis. He's the best there is! Thanks as Always!!

  Chris Knott
3 months ago
Quick,reliable and professional service. Very trustworthy and I highly recommend

  Olivia Salazar
5 years ago
Great service, super friendly staff. My fianc� and I have been taking our many cars here for years and they have never failed to diagnose and fix any and all problems. They are always up front about pricing and transparent about what repairs are necessary versus cosmetic. What finally prompted me to write this review was James going above and beyond this morning to save me money and time. He was so helpful and honest when discussing major issues with my vehicle s engine and I really appreciate his tact. Brian also gave five star service this morning and it is good to know my car is in capable hands. The waiting room is pleasant with free coffee, water, and a remote to the TV and service is fast. We love Schwartz and Nagle and trust them wholeheartedly with our cars.

  Margaret Guercio
2 years ago
Schwartz and Nagle provides the highest quality work in a timely fashion. My car required a part that isn t made anymore and the piece failed. Josef the manager took care to obtain another part and called me when it arrived. No inconvenience at all. Then they stood behind their work and did not charge me for the 2nd repair. Typical of their commitment to top notch service. I value this business in Highland Park.

  Anna McDowell
2 years ago
Big thank you to John and the team at Schwartz & Nagle Tires! A trustworthy, honest car shop with great communication and amazing customer service. Never been pressured into unnecessary repairs and have always been treated to fast and reliable service. And great deals!

  Lisa Hornick
3 years ago
Really great services and super accommodating staff! Always there to answer my questions honestly and very great at communicating. Brought my car in to get my tire pressure checked without an appointment and they took my car in right away, checked everything and even replaced my air caps for free.Love getting my oil changes here and feel comfortable getting any other work done to my car here as well.Will continue to go here as long as I live in the area and will refer many car owners here as well.

  F C
2 years ago
Had 4 new tires installed at Schwartz and Nagle four days ago. This is the only tire and mechanical place I take my business to and been doing it for a number of years. They are professional and excellent at what they do along with being trustworthy. Unlike many other services, Schwartz and Nagle is always looking out for their customer's needs. Stop searching, do yourself a favor and give S&N a call.

  Gabby Gonz
a year ago
Super affordable repair prices. Great customer service. My car repairs have always been done fast and I ve never had to wait around for hours for it to be done like other places!

  sthellman1
4 years ago
I've trusted this business for 10 years and two cars, and have never had a negative experience. If you want a professional, honest group of people for any car needs, this is for you. Tires, brakes, oil changes, spark plug, they've done it all for me at a fair price with zero problems that occurred afterwards. I can't recommend them enough if you are in Middlesex County.

  Sam Beyer
a year ago
CUSTOMERS BEWARE!!!!!This company is out to get your money.. they do not care for customer care or what is wrong for your vehicle. They Will give you a fake estimate to gain additional payments for things that are not wrong with the vehicle. Also endangered my life by allowing me to drive an unsafe car because I can guarantee they didn't even look at the car. They're unprofessionalism and incompetence is unacceptable. Terrible terrible business do not ever go here unless you want more problems then what you already went in there for. Better to look elsewhere then have a nightmare with Schwartz and nagle now with there coment stating it is untrue even in there statement on my review the OWNER of the buisness is lying and way to be professional your comment speaks volumes.... Shows what kinda customer care you got going on. To allow me to go drive off the lot with out telling me it is unsafe to drive when I even asked and was told yess by YOUR staff it was safe to drive. See everyone this is who you are dealing with....!!!??