Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods.
Service options
- Curbside pickup
Reviews
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
M.e. Thomson
a year ago
Got a turkey and cheddar sub, it was pretty good, but it was supposed to have lettuce on it but it didn t have any on it
Hunter Gatherer
a month ago
More
Bradley Rush
8 months ago
So early Sunday morning I went into Wellsville Casey's handed the lady a $50 bill she tried to give me $14 back on a $6 total on three $2 Donuts told her I handed her 50 not 20 she disagreed I asked for her to get manager and to review tapes she said she was unable to but ask for my phone number and name because she didn't want her draw to be short told her she should have been focusing on the money being handed to her instead of thinking that it was a small bill very very disappointed
Schambach Kids
2 years ago
I am new here and have came here a few mornings for breakfast. The older lady who works in the mornings was very crude and spent most of her time complaining about night shift and stated that their pizzas were nasty etc etc. I ordered pizza last night and she was very wrong! Samantha made me the BEST pizza and breadsticks I have EVER had! Not to mention some of the best service i have ever had, Its not too often that you get served with a smile! Thank you Samantha!
Jason Maskey
2 years ago
I have lived in Wellsville my entire life and for the past 6 months or more, I have had nothing but terrible encounters when ordering pizza. Every single time I have ordered, they "forgot" my order.I use to work at this very Casey's and pizza times were normally 15 to 20 mins, now they are over 30! On top of every bad experience, as tonight. They still made me pay the full amount... yea...but managment needs to do something because it is getting bad.
Samantha Ruby
2 years ago
Very good customer service and Josh in the kitchen does his thing! Best pizza and breadsticks Ive ever had from Caseys!
Marlene Stone-Godwin
a year ago
More
Paul Catterton
a year ago
Convenience store that serves your favorite snacks, beverages, pizza, sandwiches, salads and gas.
Erin
3 years ago
Staff is kind of rude and not interested in talking at all. Overall every thing is stocked.
Nick Day
a year ago
Trashy workers and don't follow corporate rules.
Jamie Koch
4 years ago
Employees are rude besides Malcom wouldn t recommend going in unless he is working
Ed
2 years ago
Fast food good service
Larry Weber
3 years ago
Smaller, older-style Casey's
Dwayne Isgrig
4 years ago
Excellent Pizza!
Ross Dwyer
6 years ago
Great place for pizza
mclovin 1993
4 years ago
Robin is the best