Ryba's Fudge Shop - Cornerstore

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Megan Thayer
8 months ago
I visited Mackinac Island last week and purchased 6 pieces of fudge! I was overwhelmed by the number of fudge places on the island but ended up at this one because some of their flavors sounded yummy!I ended up trying pistachio, chocolate, chocolate peanut butter, cherry, salted caramel and mint. Honestly, they are all delicious.I would absolutely return, or at least buy fudge online to be shipped.Also, thank you to Sarah for helping me with my selections!

  Rahul Yadav
9 months ago
They have plenty of locations on the island. The fudge was amazing. I wish we could order more than 2 flavor to try but I love the one we got too. Very thick and flavorful.

  anshul gupta
4 years ago
The outer pink exterior will definitely attract you for its fudge and ice creams. Ample varieties of fudges and ice creams. Shop has a different section for shakes as well.Peanut butter and Birthday cake are a must try. Even the fudge has a distinct quality to it which makes the place stand out.

  Michele Wiltfong
6 months ago
I moved south years ago and forgot about this place. A coworker brought in fudge from another place on the island that wasn t good, so I looked up Ryba s again. I ordered a sampler to be sent to NC. The caramel corn and brittle are amazing. The fudges were good. Though I love mint, I m not a fan of the chocolate mint option but the chocolate cherry is so good. Thanks for shipping a taste of MI to me!

  Maurielle C
7 months ago
Fudge is great. Just get it from here. Also if you stay at the island house, you get a discount. Very yummy!

  anin ayulac
8 months ago
This place serves up some of the best ice cream on the island. My fave was the Mackinac island fudge

  The Lennox bunch
7 months ago
They are such a fantastic fudge shop. If you have allergies, ask for the first batch. Our son has been able to safely enjoy fudge without worrying about his tree nut allergies.The customer service is fantastic, and the shop is always clean. We always hit Ryba's fudge whenever we hit the island.

  Nina Dershem
a year ago
Paid $20 for 2 ice cream cones and got so little ice cream and it wasn t even that good. It was $6.50 I believe for 1 scoop and $3 for an additional scoop. Does that image look like 2 scoops? It was ridiculous. Don t Go there.

  Matthew
2 years ago
Sampled some plain chocolate fudge from Ryba's, Joann's, Sander's, and Murdick's. They were all good but Ryba's was my favorite. Ryba's is definitely the creamiest fudge.

  Jonah Ups
10 months ago
We stopped at Ryba s Fudge Shop multiple times in our stay on the island and it was mostly because they had dairy free fudge/chocolate which couldn t be said of all the fudge places. They also had great dairy fudge for us to bring home to friends and family!

  Jon and Amanda Lewis
3 years ago
We got the vanilla pecan and peanut butter. So good. We also watched them scrape fudge on their big marble table. Really fun and highly recommend.

  Firoza Mistry
8 months ago
Poor salesmanship and service from Ryba Fudge, the self-proclaimed "best fudge in town".We were served poorly by their employee, who did not seem interested in selling fudge but was bidding her time till the end of her shift.Rather than helping us decide which flavor to choose, she wanted to put in minimum effort. God forbid we buy more and inconvenience her.Her supervisor or store owner who was around did nothing to improve the situation.We left in disgust and walked across to Murdicks Fudge where the sales staff was cheerful and helpful.

  Joseph
6 months ago
Fudge was good. Vegan option was decent, but very happy they offered it! Will go here next time I am on the island

  Jacob Stasa jr.
a year ago
Oh my goodness. Everything about this place is AMAZING!!! I had the strawberry pecan fudge and let me just say, that was the best fudge I ve had in my entire life! The fudge was creamy, rich, sweet but not too sweet. I was like a dream! Then we got the ice cream and oh my goodness!!!!!! That was the best ice cream I ve had in my life. You could tell it was homemade and it was so creamy and delicious!!!! This place is HIGHLY recommend by me and my 6 person family. (my brother liked the fudge so much he ate an entire bar in one night, he said he stomach hurt so bad but it was worth it.)

  Ariana Holsapple
2 years ago
Love the vegan fudge! I'm very grateful that they carry a fudge for my diet. My non-vegan family members said it tastes very good.

  Sara Ahsan
a year ago
Really cute fudge shop with pink interior. The smell that wafts through near the door is amazing! You can watch them make the fudge on granite slabs and ask for free samples!They also have pecan turtles, English toffee and salt water taffy sold by the bag or bucket.The flavor of the fudge is amazing!! It's extremely fresh and light, and the best thing is that the flavor is not too overpowering or strong. It feels like a very light and smooth taste, and not super sweet. "Chocolate no nut" and "Peanut butter" are some of their popular flavors.

  batoul alsabagh
2 years ago
Great quality ice cream and fudge, the store smells amazing

  Molly Sanford
9 months ago
Ryba's is excellent - the smell of chocolate when you walk in the door really makes it! The employees are all super nice, and Kacine was really helpful. I also like comparing between Ryba's and Kilwin's when going to Mackinac Island. Both are amazing in different ways!

  Micah Barcalow
a year ago
Our whole family was looking forward to experiencing Mackinac Island fudge. We visited several stores, but this one was clearly the winner for allergy concerns. They did an excellent job of accommodating my wife's Celiac diagnosis, and the employee was knowledgeable about the diagnosis and the process and could explain what options would be best. On top of that, the fudge was lighter and creamier than some of the other shops. We loved it!

  Jared Seguin
8 months ago
Feels like picking American over Lafayette. I go to the island just to visit here and the other fudge shop. Both are slightly different yet simply amazing.

  Ryan Soles
a year ago
I ended up buying 2 slices of Fudge, a Rocky Road and Chocolate Peanut Butter while visiting Mackinac Island. These were some of the best flavors of Fudge I have ever had. When we visit again I will definitely be buying these and maybe an additional slice.

  Jessica McLean
a year ago
We ordered Ryba s fudge for our wedding favors for our November 5th wedding. The online ordering process was so easy, customer service was awesome and fast, and the shipping was efficient and came exactly when they said it would. This was the perfect sweet take home for our northern MI wedding!

  Amy Zielke
a year ago
I didn't think I'd be buying fudge on this trip since developing a dairy allergy several years ago, but Ryba's makes dairy free chocolate fudge and it is AMAZING! The employee who sold it to us told us she actually prefers it to the regular fudge in the shop. It was seriously delicious!! I hope they branch out more in the future with some other flavors (maybe some dairy free peanut butter fudge!)

  Nicole Meiner
9 months ago
Best fudge on an island full of great fudge! I spend way more money than I have business spending at this place and I leave with no regrets every time. They are with 906 rewards too!

  KristineTest PageTest
a year ago
Friendly service and best fudge I ever had!I tried the famous original Murdicks across the street and boy, what a disappointment! Rude service, fudge hard as a rock and ultimately rather grainy. Rybas was the real deal! Nice staff, fresh fudge, so creamy! Wouldn t go anywhere else on the island for fudge, Im a Rybas loyalist!

  Kevin Malone
7 months ago
We tried 4 stores and Ryba was #3 on our list of favorites. It dropped to last when the older guy in the pink polo who I saw working in the shop almost ran me over with his bike then gave me the finger.

  Tina Glenn
9 months ago
Had a very yummy visit. The woman who sold us our fudge was the best. Thank you Racine for your help and friendly service.

  Pamela Rubright
11 months ago
Absolutely love this place. From the interior/exterior look & the wonderful smell when you walk by. The fudge and ice cream is absolutely delish! Can't go wrong with any flavor!

  Kryssy K
a year ago
I was buying fudge expecting it to be normal fudge (not vegan), but it had no butter and it was primarily with corn syrup and hydrogenated vegetable oil. It was my fault for not realizing this, but I was just heartbroken to realize I wasn't purchasing fudge made with butter. The people were very kind though and helpful in the decision process.

  Dave Mariani
3 years ago
Better than the other fudge places..way creamer...melts in your mouth..we did a taste test to prove it