Casey's

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Maura L
3 years ago
Always clean when we have gone. Employees are very nice. Good place to get pizza. We call ahead to order and it s ready in about 25 minutes. Also, fountain drinks are great and price is good as well. Definitely recommend going here if you haven t tried their pizza.

  Tim Mason
2 months ago
More

  Travis Hemry/ Alien Produckshuns
2 months ago
More

  Angela Murphy
8 months ago
These people go above and beyond constantly, regardless of the shift they are working. The crew they have right now is great!! That being said! I would love to see the flatbread pizza crust come back!!

  Preston Weaver
6 months ago
Casey's Pizza is always good... The air machine only takes card not very good in my opinion should take any form of payment

  Lynnette Rice
7 months ago
Always clean and sanitary to the Mac. Excellent customer service employees, who go above and beyond to make their people feel special and important!!Wheelchair accessibility: They are wheelchair accessible both inside and out as well as the parking itself.

  Troy Bachman
6 months ago
We prefer Casey's the people there are always friendly and nice

  Craig Brewer
a year ago
So when you order hot wings in buffalo sauce in the online ordering system it says you can do it. When I come to get my pizza and wings and you don't have any buffalo sauce then how am I suppose to eat buffalo wings? You have a new commercial out about 7 different sauces really? Can you PLEASE have more then one at this location. We don't eat blue cheese!!!!!! We have never seen more then two or three sauces ever at this location. So we stopped in at the local Dillion grocery store to get wing sauce! Maybe next time we will just get our wings at Dillons and make them ourselves. No consistency on the pizza either and it really depends on who makes it. We have heard the same name from so many in town that when he works they won't order. You literally have people calling in to see who is working. How sad is that?

  Jodie Bontrager
a year ago
Both people working were super polite and friendly! The guy by the deli made a brisket sub for me on toasted bread and it was amazing! Super polite and helpful!

  Ian Bartlett
a year ago
Excellent customer service, I wasn't able to get a hot chocolate due to a malfunctioning machine, so they gave me a free latte. Pizza is amazing, hands down best gas station pizza you can get. Very clean, and you can also get subs and sandwiches

  Daniel McNiel
6 months ago
Michelle and the rest of the crew treat you just fine

  Penny Gillis
2 years ago
Ordered meat galore ..supposed to be 13.99 special. Charged us 15.99. Ordered three pizzas... handed us 2. When we asked where the third was felt like we got attitude. Not on my list to try again

  Gloria Haire
3 years ago
Its my to go place for fresh pizza and any quick pick up. Friendly people and great service. Love there coffee when traveling always know where I can get a good cup of joe.

  Caleb Hoyt
3 years ago
Pizza soaked the box, wouldn't have happened if they set the pizza on the counter to cool.for a few.minutes before cutting. Why they don't. Explain that to their employees is a pretty big oversite.

  J
2 years ago
Actually less than 1 star. Cashier was too busy chit chatting with her friends to turn on fuel pump. They lost my business. Would have been $80 in fuel

  jennifer pugh
4 years ago
Went here this morning and no options for pizza without eggs. No option for people in any breakfast besides donuts for people with egg allergies or who do not eat bacon or sausage. Also picked up a Starbucks cold coffee and it was expired in April!

  Elizabeth Tuszynski
5 years ago
Very good customer service. Nice, new, clean store. Best chain pizza you can get anywhere for miles.

  Aimee Jones
2 years ago
Disappointed in our pizza this evening. Seems like you've changed your recipe or neglected to put any tomato sauce on the bottom crust?

  Mike Ryan
3 years ago
Casey's in Sterling is just a nice place. The people that work there are great! The pizzas are the best.

  Leonard Ramsey
4 years ago
Best food ever! Super clean store and restrooms. People are very friendly, professional and helpful

  JA Y
7 months ago
RJ is the best with the pizza skills

  Kenneth Nickerson
2 years ago
Friendly people, convenient location and a good selection of quick food and beverages

  jelstun101
7 months ago
More

  Andy Stout
3 years ago
Casey's has the best ice and tea in town. Friendly people all around

  Lorry Rasnic
5 years ago
Good place to go. Clean restrooms and a couple places to sit down and eat!!

  Ryker Kelly
2 years ago
Delicious pizza! Great service.

  Mark Ude
3 years ago
Gotta love this place. Convenience store with all you need.

  Billie Mcvey
8 months ago
Friendly helpful staff in v

  John Burnett
7 months ago
More

  Carol Gardner
2 years ago
I always use Casey's in Lyons friendly people