Casey's

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Connie Holton
5 months ago
My fianc� goes to lunch at 630 most evenings and there are times he likes to stop and get us a slice of pizza for dinner. There have been numerous times that he has stopped in there to get pizza and they don t have any. It s disappointing and a waist of his lunch. Do better!!

  Elise Richard
7 months ago
So I went in and got a pizza took it home had no sauce, I came back with and was hoping I would get a new pizza. They not only gave me a new pizza but while I wait gave me a drink on the house for the inconvenience. Not only that but how they talked and were friendly towards everyone that came in is amazing!! Best Casey s in my opinion.

  Vanessa Childs
9 months ago
I love Casey's because they have a great selection and good deals on a lot of their items but one thing that really makes me frustrated is the breakfast pizza. I usually go in almost everyday and there never is the breakfast pizza WITH the gravy! It seems to be the cheese sauce? Which makes the pizza taste... Not the same. It's ok but that's NOT a breakfast pizza. I would love for there to be more of them and better labeling on the type of pizza, if it was gravy or cheese sauce, etc. I don't like to order a whole pizza JUST to get the gravy. There are enough shelves in that pizza warmer that this could be a possibility.

  Randall and Mary Retherford
10 months ago
Maybe when you are overwhelmed at work you should not take it out on the customers, or just take a smoke break and settle down! Don't make smart comments to me about this and that and tell ME I'm rushing you. I was just making small talk and trying to ease your obvious tension. Guess that's a bad idea! We have had issues with this Casey's since moving here over a year ago. Don't get Doordash from here, it will take forever. If you are also a Dasher, expect to wait for your customer order for a while because they won't even acknowledge your existence in the store. To top it all off my debit card is now having issues because this morning I was told a transaction didn't go through only for it go through and then ran it again and now I have 2 reversals on my card which the bank will flag! That was the last straw for us. There are other Casey's in town that are newer and nicer who will now be getting out future business.

  Pedro Rodriguez, Jr
2 years ago
Ordered a pizza and some breadsticks tonight. And waited almost two hours called them back and they said DoorDash never picked up my order. They never called now I have to wait on. A refund. This is totally not okay.

  gary certain
6 months ago
I want to thank the evening crew Friday evening at the Casey's for their honesty thanks you guys

  STEPHANIE ESTREMERA
6 years ago
this is actually my favorite gas station! i generally get gas at Kroger, but if i'm ever in a area where there isn't a Kroger or i i don't have and Kroger Fuel points, then Casey's is my go to gas station. They have really good food too. and honestly, their breakfast pizza is the best thing ever. hands down! they have the BEST breakfast pizza you will ever eat.

  Zachariah Hoffman
4 years ago
The manager John was super nice! Met him on Christmas day. Really went out of his way to make sure customers were happy. That man deserves a raise!

  Mark Stevens
5 years ago
I go here every morning and get something and don't go to outher gastations in terre haute cause they are all dirty but the Casey's usually if not always are clean decent prices but I am writing this review cause I bought heat hands to keep my hands worm but they put them on the rack instead of in the box and one of them is defective so I am shore they all will have one that is bad just saying

  Dag G.
2 years ago
Ordered online for delivery, delivery person was amazing, and the pizza & bread sticks were super delicious! Very generous on the pizza toppings too!

  Mandalyn Grubb
4 years ago
Great veggie pizza, juicy and they don't skimp at all on the veggies! Also great cheesy bread but I wish it was more/bigger.

  Nicholas Bowser
3 years ago
Delicious pizza for an amazing price. Friendly staff and a free air hose to air up your tires.

  Dustin Tedder
5 years ago
At 9:00 was just getting gas, fill my tire up, and pick up a pack of cigarettes. The attendant was very rude to me, i will not becoming back!

  Dawn Stuffle
6 years ago
The people are really nice and helpful and a very clean the food is great so go see for yourself

  D L
4 years ago
Dea made the best sub ive ever had at a Caseys. My go to location now.

  Angela Ashley
5 years ago
Super friendly and helpful staff. I've never had anyone be rude there.

  Tom Bryant
3 years ago
Best Casey's in town! I love the staff! I love the pizza!

  Dalton Drake
3 years ago
Best pizza best service around an friendly workers!

  Matt Foltz
3 years ago
Air compressor i stop there for didn't work. Had to get towed out. Didn't go inside

  Jeffery Isle (Henry)
3 years ago
Regular Casey's its my home base one so I like it more

  gary richards
3 years ago
Fair pizza, but could improve their crust.

  Steve M
5 years ago
Good fast service. Always a good experience coming here.

  Tj Tjl lee
3 years ago
Polite I'm very good pizza

  Ale D
3 years ago
Very bad experience. I won't be going back.

  Troy Freeman
3 years ago
Great Pizza, love the cookies

  Patty Cannoy
3 years ago
Just stopped to go to restroom and get a drink.

  Neil Kale
2 years ago
Pizza gave me food poisoning

  Kelli Rohr
3 years ago
Great service and good pastries.

  John Morris
6 years ago
Excellant and very quick and polite service

  Lee Ann Gilbert
3 years ago
Ok servive and friendly enough