Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods.
Service options
- Curbside pickup
Reviews
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Derek Akers
2 months ago
More
Tank Lewis
7 months ago
The absolute worst Casey's in the state of Indiana, which is a shame used to be good, spent 56 on pizza and pop the pizza were undercooked wrong crust , didn't receive the beverages or chips when my old lady picked it up a turn style of employees, go to shelburn
Taylor Kanen
a year ago
I've been a religious customer of the store for almost a year since moving to Sullivan. The assistant manager, Pearl, has been nothing but rude, giving attitude when asked questions, and she doesn't stay off her phone. Her attitude has made me not want to come back. The other staff are great and a pleasure to be with, the food is great, but the morale when pearl is around I've noticed is non existant. Being super young with a big head doesn't help.
Heaven Casas
3 years ago
Another win in my book for Casey's here in Sullivan! Free to use air hoses to get your tires to the right PSI! I think it should be this way everywhere.. but I've paid even 1.75 for air.
Hayden Br8ar
a year ago
I tried to order a chicken wrap and it took over 30 min to pick up the phone and then tell me we don't do those tonight lier's ur just lazy and pathetic I hope they close this store down because you guys are going down hill
Ben King
2 years ago
Custom ordered the loaded breakfast burritos for the family. Worth the wait! They truly were loaded to the brim and tasted great!
Alicia Risley
2 years ago
Have always been a fan of their breadsticks until recently they re cheesy bread has changed and it is horrible taste is great but the quantity isn t there.
Edwina Hurt
3 years ago
I had to stop going there and they only have one kind of gas and that's the cheapest and it made my car run really bad I love being able to go in and get pizza
Phil Baker
3 years ago
Good rewards program. They have gas. Pizza is cheap but ok tasting, as I type this from the bathroom :/
John C. Klemme
a year ago
Pearl made the P-E-R-F-E-C-T late night pie! We enjoyed every bite! NOM NOM NOM...
Chris G
a year ago
Top flight staff, always friendly and helpful. Great pizza!
Travis Stout
3 years ago
The pizza is great. Everyone should go get one.
Patricia Pitts
5 years ago
Hardly any sauce on their pizza! All crust and cheese! Put some tomatoe or pizza sauce on it!
jason wright
3 years ago
It gas station pizza what else can you expect
ryanstout88
4 years ago
Rarely have any breakfast ready until 5.30am
George Lloyd
a year ago
Get pizza from there regularly
Rayana Overton
6 years ago
Employees didn't great me
karen Dicus
9 years ago
crazy people work there
Amanda Hellis
4 years ago
Love the pizza
James Bishop
3 years ago
Good service.
Bill Collins
3 years ago
Fast and friendly
Will Conway
6 years ago
Open late!!!