Casey's

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Jenna Franks
8 months ago
Best food item I ve EVER gotten from Casey s anywhere! I travel a lot and go to many many Casey s. I ve never even seen this type of sandwich offered before. 5 stars from the hubby & I.The nice lady cooking said she can make anything customized, just ask

  Kylie Lane
a month ago
More

  Catlady Lover
2 months ago
More

  Gabrielle Davis
5 months ago
More

  Timothy Germain
2 years ago
Love their Pizza. Little greasy if you get the pepperoni like me unfortunately that's all my kids will eat but I still enjoy their Pizza very much and definitely will get more.

  Ronda Miller
7 months ago
UPDATE!! -- BAD & GETTING WORSEThe ladies up front are wonderful, mostly!However, now the 4th time we went in to pick up our pizza order (2 orsers online & 2 via phone) AFTER the approximate pick up time (allowing an extra 5-10 minutes) and the guy making the pizzas hadn't even STARTED them yet. THIS KEEPS HAPPENING!!! Why give pick-up times if you aren't going to adhear to any schedule.Additionally,Each time we have tried the new thin & crispy crust, the pizza is burnt. Finally, we order two or three pizzas at a time and at least one of our pizza's toppings is wrong on every order. Bad and getting worse!

  Ian S
a year ago
The man who works on the pizzas and other food in the back does a great job. Food is always fresh, tastes great, and never burnt. Store is mostly stocked and clean. Parking lot is decent. Cashier's are kind and helpful.

  Andrea Carmichael
3 years ago
The employees are great and they keep the stors clean. Also depending on who is working they make a good pizza ect. I was their today though and there is a sign on the door that says masks required. But not one employee had a mask on but the cook. They looked at me like I was nuts when I had mine on. Made me feel uncomfortable. I don't like to wear the mask as much as everyone else. But

  Enrique Ortiz (Rick)
2 years ago
More

  Chris Kosary
5 years ago
I am giving this place 2 starts because it is pretty clean and we'l lit. My reason for stopping at 5:30 pm was to grab a quick bite. McDonald's was closed for renovations and the only other option was either sit down or wait in line for an over priced sub at Subway. Casey's has pizza by the slice so I was going to grab and go.Guess what. No slices of pizza. No sandwiches. Nothing. The clerk was busy chatting with someone and when I tried to call Casey's customer service, I got voicemail that told me to leave a message and they should get back to me in a couple of days.Sorry. Doesn't cut it.

  Kimberly Burge
5 years ago
This place is a joke, I ordered a large cheese pizza, 35 minutes is what the guy said, I get there and my pizza wasn't even made, said they didn't get the order. They asked if I wanted to wait 40 more minutes , are you kidding me right now?!? Above all it was the kitchen manager who took the order. Wow ....I will never order from them , Ridiculous.....

  Henry G
5 years ago
I never had a problem there. They always been nice to me and my pizzas was really for me. Pizza always cooked good and ordered was right. I order from there like 1 time a week. So far no problems

  Theresa Hill
2 years ago
Everyone is very nice, helpful & the store is clean. As far as the mask MANDATE, it's just that. . NOT a law. If you are that scared wear your face diaper or stay home. Thank you Casey's.

  Todd Frazier
3 years ago
I bought 4 tiny chicken strips and paid $5.13!! Absolutely nutz!! As small as they are they shouldn't be more then $2.99!!

  Eduardo j Cornejo
a year ago
More

  David Adams
5 years ago
Always good to us when we stop. I have not had any food there other than drinks and donuts when stopping for gas while traveling through.

  Jonathan Rose
2 years ago
More

  Chris Kent
3 years ago
Staff as well as patrons totally ignore the State law concerning masks. Ya'll watch the numbers go up every day. GROW UP AND MASK UP!!THIS IS THE ONLY COMPLAINT I HAVE AS A REGULAR CUSTOMER.

  Lindsay Berndt
3 years ago
Sign on the door says face masks required. Not one employee or customer (except myself) had a mask on.

  Frank Potochney
2 months ago
More

  Susan Brewster
3 years ago
Yum pizza already made.The best pizza in my town

  Audrey Pegues
5 years ago
Horrible experience. Hopefully the clerk was just having an off night & doesn t treat all customers like I was treated.

  Christal Hubbard
3 years ago
Great people and great service. Love the food too

  K D
3 years ago
Out of goodland and remmington caseys, Kentland caseys has by far the best caseys pizza

  Tim Cadle
6 years ago
Everybody friendly gas station was clean just everybody just very very very helpful

  bartimus 3
5 years ago
Food is always good. Staff is always friendly.

  Jami Wicker
6 years ago
Clean, friendly staff, excellent pizza and sub's

  Raychell Pirowski
6 years ago
They take way too long to cook their pizzas

  Linda Nelson
6 years ago
Best casey store around.

  Donald Furr
3 years ago
Well stocked and friendly.