Casey's

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Sarah Brown (sarahhhjane317)
2 months ago
The worst gas station of all gas stations. They won t actually pay their employees an acceptable wage so don t ever expect them to have anything in stock (the way it should be). They receive shipments of drinks that are to go in the cooler but the employees won t put them in there. They will actually just sit the full rack of drinks on the floor or a shelf and just leave them there. The employees all complain about the stores management and literally none of them do anything that actually benefit the customers. I won t even go here anymore bc I know if I want something, they ll be out of it or it won t be available the way the item is supposed to be.PAY YOUR EMPLOYEES BETTER SO THEY ACTUALLY DO THEIR JOBS.

  Stephanie Feece
6 months ago
Ordered a breakfast pizza. Wanted 1 half with sausage and 1 half with bacon. When we went to pick it up, discovered it was 1 half double sausage and 1 half no bacon. They offered to fix it and have it ready within 15 minutes. Went in to pick up the supposedly correct pizza. It was the exact same mistake as the first pizza. I told them I wasn't going to wait anymore and would just take the mistake pizza. They then charged me full price! Never ordering from there again.

  Brooke Street
2 years ago
Came to the store this morning at 5am waiting 10 mintues for them to open even though they are supposed to open at 5. Finally left as employee watched me drive away. Still not opening the store. Ordered online pizza and wings. Got home to find none of the dipping sauces were in with the order. Never ordering again or trying to stop there in the mornings

  C Jedi meek
5 months ago
More

  Adam Gillam
2 years ago
Sorry Casey's but I'm gonna point out something that most don't seem to notice. Overall I like the gas station and the pizza. The issue I have is your convenience store prices never ring up the price on the shelf and the kids running the cash registers could care less when you tell them the price rang up wrong. With the small selection of items you actually sell you could easily scan all the items in a few hours to confirm your labels are correct. I did you a favor and pulled a few of your labels on the shelf so your next customer doesn't have the same experience I did last night. Please do everyone a favor and check your labels with the price that's in your system. Right now you are up to $3.24 in items I have been overcharged for according to your own advertised price . You will notice you are missing 3 labels on your Kellogg's breakfast bars. Your labels showed .99 cents but they rang up $1.19 so you will need to replace those with the new price since it appears you had a price increase. If you multiply that out over say 2000 different customers a month then you have illegitimately made ~$6480 off of your customers without them realizing it. Please let me know where I should send in to get my refund

  Matt P
2 years ago
This place used to be the place a lot of people would go after work to grab a pizza or sandwich on their way home or to the gym. Now I can't order takeout past 10pm? Red Gold gets out at 10pm and Elsa gets out around 11pm. Big waste of an opportunity to make money if you ask me. Will not be back until you're open 24/7 like you were until the plandemic.

  Josh Velten
7 months ago
More

  badams
a year ago
Last Friday didn't have meat thawed out for pizza, this Friday shutting down the oven for the night at 4pm, on a Friday

  Jesse Underwood
a year ago
Will never order pizza from here again. Order was an hour late. Wasn t correct. The staff acted like they hated their jobs and life

  Amber Harmon
4 years ago
Don't Get Gas from Casey gas station!! They stole $.84 in gas from me. Last 2 times I got gas there, I had an issue. Their manager seemed to be intoxicated, and couldn't understand simple English. I will not be going back there anytime soon!

  Justin Beagle
a year ago
Ok place if you can catch them when they are open. They are very hit or miss in the morning. I assume that's because they pay their employees so low they don't want to come in at 6am

  B Humphries
4 years ago
Great location on west side of town. They have free air for tires. Great coffee, especially the iced coffee! Everyone is always very friendly!

  Tim Jones
6 years ago
Had a great experience at Casey's i called the Elwood Indiana Casey's General store and ordered a taco pizza and a sausage pizza and bread sticks and of course i got sodas and smokes and the Elwood Call-Leader and every employee in the store were awesome very friendly..Thank you to the employee's at theElwood Indiana Casey's General Store Tim Jones

  Boom Stick4287
2 years ago
Jamie Kelly and lilly are by far the best people in town I love them so much always make you feel welcome

  KY Bear
2 years ago
Dont have Caseys here in Kentucky, but they are the place I choose to stop at for work in Indiana. Correction: I happened to come by a Casey's in Carrollton, KY

  SKULL0FD3ATH
3 years ago
Management doesn't do the greatest at keeping employees safe, employee's are toxic to one another, store manager hasn't been doing her job to enforce rules with covid19 do not recommended this location or company as a whole.

  mark nemyer
5 years ago
The service in the morning is horrible.. we walk get our stuff go to the register witch was previously occupied with a clerk mind you she is nowhere to be seen Shea lost our money I'll just go to speedway they know how to stay at the register

  Ash k
3 years ago
Used to have amazing food and tons of options. Now they never seem to have breakfast ready and precooked foods are old.

  Carla McClish
3 years ago
The employees are courteous in Elwwod and Tipton locations. Always impressed with the service plus great food!

  Jennifer Ritchie
3 years ago
I don't know how ive made it all these years with my weekly dose of Casey's cheese pizza. Love the perks!

  Kristopher Groover
6 years ago
Casey's has really good food for the size of the cook area never changing yet they serve and del I cer

  Steffhan Taylor
3 years ago
Love this place. Great cashiers, Awesome food A++++

  Lucina Carter
3 years ago
Let just say sense the new manager to over the store has REALLY went down hill.

  Jeffrey Scales
2 years ago
Great pizza, fresh donuts every morning,

  Cliffdiver97
4 years ago
Great food made to order 24/7

  Sizelove's family
6 years ago
Great delivery super fast time friendly place

  Sonya Balser
3 years ago
Loving those caramel cinnamon rolls! MmmMmm Good

  Tim Jones
3 years ago
Very friendly have great pic pizza

  Josh Stansberry
a year ago
Cute girl complimented my gages

  clayton huff
6 years ago
Always pleasant and friendly. Enjoy shopping there.