Casey's

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Mike Wheeler
6 months ago
I haven't order pizza from Casey's since 2020 because I moved to Kokomo. But today I ordered three large pizzas, one breakfast sausage and two premiums and they were as good as I remember them being three years ago, delicious Pizza!!

  Travis H
6 days ago
More

  Donna Dorsey
9 months ago
We absolutely love Casey's pizzaWe don't eat pizza from anywhere else now! Rheann is amazing and so,so pleasant! She went out of her way for me. I can't walk in so she brought my food out and even put it in the car for me also! She fixed a darn good pizza too! very, very good!

  ARKANJEL
a year ago
I stop here almost daily. Staff is always pleasant and helpful. Never have to wait and if you're hungry, great place to stop abd grab some hot food! Yum to the chicken strips and ! Also, if you use the Upside app, I often get 18 cents off per gallon at Casey's vs maybe 8 cents at Speedway.

  JT Copas
2 years ago
I ordered 3 pizzas online, I was a bit apprehensive afraid that it might be too much of an order at once for them to handle. My wife picked them up and they were all ready on time and very delicious... Which is why I ordered them in the first place! Thank you Casey's!

  Jeremy Lawless
a year ago
Hands down best pizza in the area. They are always nice and polite. I love the staff in this place. Me and my family order dinner from there often. Highly recommend the Arcadia Casey's.

  Kevin Rejko
3 years ago
Waited half an hour after my pick up tom for my pizza and cheese bread. Cashier acted like he could not be bothered. Was just standing there eating pizza off the pizza warmer at the counter and drinking his drink. He could ot would not help the cook catch up but had time to go outside for a smoke break....its just sad....spend 30 dollars on food and its lukewarm when you get it. Told them when I got there I was waiting on an online order and it still didn't dawn on him that it was my order so I stood there 30 mins while my food got cold

  Tucker Epperson
5 years ago
Great pizza and probably some of the best donuts I have ever eaten. The staff have always been nice people. It is a bit pricy but worth it to me. The surprising thing for its location is they do not sell diesel.

  Jeffery Whitesid
6 years ago
I ordered boneless wings one Friday evening at 9pm. I showed up, and they did not make my order/see my order online. I live in town, and I m here every day. I will say this, they made it right. I have had good and bad here, but the customer service has always been top notch. From 6am, to 10pm, they care 100%.

  Carla Black
2 years ago
Not to busy quick convienient little gas station. Staff was extra nice. Everything was easy to find in this Casey's. Store was very clean. I will be stopping here again next time I drive through.

  Terri Hale
6 years ago
I called in an order for a sandwich and some wedge fries and they told me it would be 30 min because they had 2 orders ahead of me. I waited 30 min and went to pick my order up and they looked at me like I was stupid and said they never cooked my order. I told them to forget it and drove to Cicero to Rallys. I live in Arcadia and thought I would spend my money in my own town. Won't waste my time with them again.

  Jason Cornman
6 years ago
Made an online order and it wasn't ready. Waited 10 mins and they still hadn't put my wings in. They said they were going to make it right. In the end, I waited about 25 mins before they handed me an order. When I got back to work and I opened everything up, I did not get one thing that I actually ordered. I should have checked before I left but I was now late getting back to work and trying to hurry.

  Brandon Foutz
2 years ago
Never has anything in stock and always makes you wait 30-40 minutes longer than told when you go to pick up pizza 30-45 minutes after ordering. Horrible staff as well

  Adam Knoll
3 years ago
The workers are very friendly and I really enjoy the coffee. Pizza is very good. Love the breakfast pizza.

  Elizabeth Gray
3 years ago
Like these small town convienent stores. Pizzas are yummy and nice coffee choices. Helpful staff.

  S marson
3 years ago
I used to buy pizzas from our local Casey's when i was living in iowa yrs a go. Still worth buying at any Casey's you might go to today.

  Robin Muterspaugh
a year ago
Thanks to Casey's breakfast pizza was for breakfast after driving to Cicero McDonald's and they were closed again!

  Angela Angelize007 Darden
3 years ago
Casey's has the best pizza ! And the staff is great as well!

  Dakota Altum
2 years ago
More

  deborah sneed
3 years ago
Casey s has really good coffee. And great bakery items

  Justin Schultz
3 years ago
No masks on employees, very few on customers. A good place to avoid for the foreseeable future.

  michael white
3 years ago
So, I was stuck at a train in Alex. CASEYS wouldn't cook breakfast during the lockdown for their essential customers...

  TJ Tryon
8 years ago
Best pizza in Arcadia. Decent gas prices, good little selection of convenience store goods.

  Troll
10 months ago
I hung up after 3 minutes of waiting on the phone for someone to answer!

  Joy Ride
7 years ago
Awesome staff and great little shop for our town!

  Steve Stone
3 years ago
This is the BEST gas station in the entire world!

  Josh Stansberry
a year ago
Good gass

  Joy Dewalt
3 years ago
Had exactly what I wanted when other places were sold out.

  Wanda Russ
3 years ago
Love the breakfast pizza with gravy!

  Colin Kaurich
5 years ago
Best pizza in Hamilton county