Casey's

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Jessica Kupiec
2 years ago
I used to enjoy Casey's very much. I won't get gas there because they make u prepay or pay at the pump. And I don't do either. But I love their doughnuts and pizza. They're breadsticks were amazing. But they changed those. So we don't even order them anymore. Same with the chicken. And they used to deliver to my location. They recently stopped that. With absolutely no notice. We were pretty regular and left good tips. So pretty much, went from a couple times a week. To maybe once a month or so. Very disappointed.

  Deborah Carman
3 years ago
Always great pizza, homemade Ingredients and baked just right! They offer many good items like their iced sugar cookies, subs, and brownie bites. I am sad they're not serving potato wedges anymore though... We loved getting them with a cheeseburger. Their cheeseburgers, popcorn chicken, and subs are fantastic. Friendly staff, great hours...a great place to get gas and treats.

  Lauren Jackson
a year ago
My family's always loved having their donuts for breakfast. This was my first time having their pizza and it was pleasantly delicious. I Can't wait to order it again.

  Amanda Pirtle
a year ago
This is the worst Casey's ever. I generally go out of my way to go to a Casey's but in this case I'll go out of my way to avoid it. They are always out of everything. Their gas pumps are always broken.

  michael mcdermith
3 years ago
Walked in the store stood at the counter while two ladies stood in the kitchen and chatted it up for about oh id say five ten minutes, walked over two or three times to get someones attention, finally just asked for my pizza and bread sticks, took it home, opend the box and the pizza is soo greasy literally all my cheese and toppins fell off the slice and the grease is dripping off the soggy grease soaked crust from waayyyy too many toppings on the pizza, absolutely disgusting... wont be going back to mtz caseys!!!

  Chad Carroll
3 years ago
Always have what I need. Nice and polite employees. Rewards card and the BEST pizza!! Either whole or by the slice.

  Ryan Krieger
7 years ago
Seems like their gas prices are always the cheapest in Macon County! Plus they are one of very few stores who stock Mr. Pibb! Very friendly service!

  Taylor Randall
5 years ago
Ordered a medium chicken bacon ranch and when I get there I notice the special is a large chicken bacon ranch for the same price as medium. Would have been nice of the worker to mention the special.

  Carol Ferguson
6 years ago
The. Pizza is the best. Clerks are nice. Friendly and helpful people work there and bathroom is kept clean

  Karen Tharp
5 years ago
Love their pizza! Always friendly staff and great to stop in for coffee or soft drinks!

  Bob Stevenson
5 years ago
Everything is usually clean. Always helpful people around. The Food always tastes good. Also simple work at fast rate. $$

  Mike Gillenwater
a year ago
Why is your gas 20 cents to 40 cents higher than Decatur and other Casey's??

  Judy Repinski
3 years ago
Love their pizzas! Always a pleasant delivery person.

  CARS AND BARS - Joshua Williams
3 years ago
Great pizza! Friendly staff! And the delivery driver is great!

  Susan Zientara
3 years ago
Ordered pepperoni pizza, under cooked, the crust was so limp had to roll up to eat it. Yuck

  Joe Chase
3 years ago
It's just the best gas station ever created.... Not my fault it just is.

  Tom Shelton
6 years ago
Nice and clean. Has a sandwich shop in it. Great donuts. Towels in the bathroom.

  Pam Roberts
3 years ago
Love going to Casey's. Donuts are the yummiest!

  Nonya Kate Business
2 years ago
I love you, C(K)as(sio)ey. I do.

  Felivi Xantri
6 years ago
Consistent pizza and sticks, sadly their slushy machine is frequently down.

  Plado
7 years ago
Good, simple store. Has fishing bait as well.

  Katherine Majors
3 years ago
Love the assistant manager Cheryl is so nice

  Carl Johnson
5 years ago
Great place to stop in for a coffee or soda.

  LaRae Roberts
5 years ago
Best Pizza in town!

  Jeff Evans
3 years ago
One of the best in town!

  Gary Howard
3 years ago
good place always friendly

  Nichole Farrow
3 years ago
Pizza was over cooked.

  Chaos Crutcher
3 years ago
Love the rewards

  Penny Newberry
3 years ago
Good