Casey's

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Scott Pickering
a year ago
The staff is usually friendly and the food is okay. Really need a new store in town. What I would like to see more than anything, bring back the Mac and Cheese Pizza. It's missed.

  Sarah Castiaux
3 years ago
I love their pizzas. Their original crust is just so soft that it almost melts in your mouth. If someone with no teeth can eat it with no problems then I recommend it very highly.

  Patrick Evans
a year ago
1st time getting bad grab and go pizza. It was like concrete. And I guess the clerk takes smoke breaks when customers are waiting. Then proceeds to cough like he has the plague, whilst not covering his mouth. Bathroom was clean.

  Lindsay S.
3 years ago
Terrible service. Whichever lady works at night answering phones/taking food orders does a poor job. They have forgotten our order twice with no call back AND cancelled our online delivery after it was placed without telling us because they do not deliver on Wednesdays . Do you want ppl to keep coming back? You should probably work on communicating with your customers. After reading other reviews about the Casey s on Prairieview road, it is clear that this is an issue. Hoping to see an improvement in the future.

  Ryan Wingard
5 years ago
I so appreciate our local Casey's in Mahomet. The pizza and salads are so fresh and well done. I feel like the employees take pride in putting out a good product. The delivery people are very kind and courteous.

  Jim Zavorka
6 months ago
Always clean diesel pumps, and very well stocked!

  Lisa Stratman
4 years ago
I placed an online order at 5:33 p.m. this evening for a pizza to be delivered at 7:30 p.m. I started calling at 8:15 p.m. with nobody answering the phone. Finally at 8:30 I was able to speak with someone who said the delivery people just left and to give them 10-15 more minutes. Pizza arrived and was extremely underbaked and doughy as well as not a single slice had been cut through the crust. This was the worst service we have had at this Caseys and can say we will not be back. It should never take three hours to underbake a pizza!!

  Dan Cahill
5 years ago
5 stars overall, BUT Casey's corporation is out of this world REDICULOUSLY high on some items, case in point, $5 for a 4lb bag of sugar.Also Casey's has GREAT pizza.BUT corporate in it's infinite wisdom has mandated that ALL storesNOT deliver after 9PM EVEN ONWEEKENDSABSOLUTELY REDICULOUSSeems to me like corporate is shooting themselves in the foot.(This was mandated less than 6 mos. ago ).

  Jennifer Malloch
7 years ago
Your typical Casey's gas station. Good pizza, not so great wings, overcooked but under iced donuts most of the time. I do like the addition of ice cream but they do turn that machine off during the winter months.

  BL4CKP4P3RM00N
6 years ago
A really garbage store with some less then capable employees. Some are high, some are drunk, the managers can t manage and while the food taste okay sometimes only a very few employees are really worth anything and most of the time the person making your stuff makes you wonder if you really want to even mess with it. I mean there is a Fallipos down the street I don t have to worry about. And i would like to say the staff heavily reflects their managers. They re the type of guys that will give one guy time off for a party but not another to mourn a recent death. Maybe it s because they sympathize for the first one and it reflect them.

  MaddMoxxi B
5 years ago
The people were nice and helpful. I order a large pizza and some breadsticks. The food was wonderful. So all in all this place is great. They all seem very hometown proud.

  Rshaun Smith
3 years ago
This is a great store! The staff is super friendly, food is good, especially the breakfast sandwiches. Good pizza too

  Majora s_Mask1998
5 years ago
Some of the workers aren't the cleanest.. and they're making my Pizza.. which makes me just want to get Pizza hut.. my personal opinion. I'm sure others would agree.

  KawaiiMittyNeko
3 years ago
It's a nice place, if you need to refuel, get some pizza or early breakfast. Pretty much a standard Casey's.

  Dalton Day
4 years ago
I like this place. It's the best. One employee is my grandma! Breakfast pizza is the bomb!

  Paul Jordan
6 years ago
Heather was extremely helpful while ordering my breakfast pizza. Breakfast pizza is really good. A+!

  Thomas Roe
3 years ago
Always has great pizza. Store is clean and staff is friendly.

  Ella Hale
3 years ago
Never once has my pizza been on time or the order correct. I've about given up.

  robert fillers
3 years ago
Good pizza an drinks be ok if didn't have to wear a mask

  Violet Turnbo
2 years ago
Just came in to pickup the pizza I ordered online and they said they forgot to make my pizza..

  Monet Johnson
6 years ago
Great service really clean store and the pizza is the best

  Mary Pettenger
5 years ago
Annie is amazing. She is always so friendly and welcoming!

  Derek Bettner
6 years ago
Very greasy and didn't even tasteb like Casey's pizza

  Matthew Jones
11 years ago
I have been calling them for the past hour and they aren't answering my call! I need a freakin TACO PIZZA!

  Karen Myers
3 years ago
Love their Pizza and their Specials!!!

  Ashley Evans
4 years ago
Friendly service. Annie is the best!

  Bryan moore
3 years ago
Little bit of everything. Like the rewards app

  Jean Auteberry
4 years ago
Very friendly. Fast service

  Michael Cox
3 years ago
Good value, great taste!

  Linda Richardson
3 years ago
Good friendly customer service