Convenience-store chain offering fuel, drinks & food, including pizza, sandwiches & baked goods.
Service options
- Curbside pickup
Reviews
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Cade Grimm
9 months ago
I have been going to this location for over 25 years and for the most part I have never had any complaints. Lately things seem to be going south and I don't want this to be taken as an attack, but rather some constructive criticizm. The staff are always very friendly and helpful but there seems to be something going on with the way the store is being managed. A couple weeks ago they were out of large pizza boxes. No big deal. But yesterday I placed an online order and I got a call almost immediately to let me know they were out of both pepperoni and frying oil for wings. The last couple times I actually was able to walk out with a pizza they didn't seem to be up to the standard I've always been accustomed to. I always promote Casey's pizza to everyone. I always tell people how much better it is than all the big chains. To the management - I understand that sometimes there are circumstances that create issues that are beyond your control; problems with refrigeration, understaffing, supply chain issues, power outages, etc. But there really needs to be some effort to make some course corrections because it's getting harder for me to recommend anyone to this location. Bethany is a small town and there is little competition. Please don't let that fact persuade you to lower your standards or eventually it will cause people to lower their expectations.
Annie Swearingen
a year ago
Stopped at Casey s after the joke of an owner at the marathon gas station in mt Zion wanted us to pay for our $30 in snacks before using their restroom. Casey s was very clean. Smelled of cleaner in the restrooms. And all the workers was amazingly nice. Especially the one working the register. Definitely a way better place to do business.
Cory Simpson
6 years ago
All the employees are wonderful. Always clean and kept up. Awesome pizza, and they have hot slices at the ready all day.
Carrie C
15 years ago
The correct phone number for bethany is 665-3661.Great pizza at this store, best of any Casey's I've ever tried. :)
Talesha Ledbetter
10 years ago
Awesome pizza if there is a old guy Cooke say lary tell him Zarred told u to it lol he will get it lol.
Peggy K
6 years ago
Good place to stop. Friendly & kind employees! Good pizza
Brent Phillips
3 years ago
Great food, drinks and service!!
Amy B
2 years ago
Great service and friendly staff
Gary Howard
3 years ago
all ok good service
Harvey Phillips
3 years ago
Clean store, friendly staff
Penny Newberry
3 years ago
Good
jessy lillico
6 years ago
Friendly service
Jill Sunderland
6 years ago
Clean
Michael Burley
3 years ago
It's caseys
Sara Craft
7 months ago
More
John Gilbert
10 months ago
More