Casey's

Reviews

Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.

  Brian Chambers
3 weeks ago
Ordered pizza and bread sticks 3-27-25 7:30pm. Went there cheese sticks were done no worker in site. The put the pizza behind the cheese sticks and the pizza remained in the over due to workers on break . This is the second time this has happened to us in 2 weeks. Told manager, she didn t care basically told me that mistakes happen.. no one cares to do a quality job anymore and wants 15$ an hour I buy my gas 3 times a week at Casey s. Beardstown store needs work.

  Stacie Baze
4 months ago
We got a supreme pizza and when we got the first one it was so doughy we couldn't eat it. We took it back. They made a new and the second one was the same way. All the toppings were in the middle of the pizza causing it to not cook right. The crust was thick on one side and thin on the other. We also ordered the cheese bread and it was so thin and hard I couldn't even eat it.

  Michael McCloskey
5 months ago
Frequent here often, always been good people and having product. Try the breakfast burrito, pretty good.

  Lisa Romano
2 months ago
More

  SuperDaltonTheGamer
a year ago
I ll give them five stars because their pizza is really good but I am a little sad and disappointed they don t do the delivery anymore but that s still OK

  Pito Pas
4 years ago
Just ordered a pizza, first one was burned then after waiting for the second one i get home and noticed its not cooked all the way trough ! The sauce for my cheese sticks its brick cold ! Who ever is cooking for them is not doing it with much love!

  Cary Miller
6 years ago
Very friendly staff at this location. The breakfast pizzas are extremely good and the doughnuts are pretty good also. Well stocked with convenience store items. Store is kept clean.

  Donald Busby
5 years ago
Friendly employees, clean atmosphere, and good food.

  Dylan Passmore
2 years ago
Usually good food. Always overpriced. The cashier did not honor the buy one get one even though no dates were on the promo.

  Ron Blakeman
a year ago
The Beardstown store needs to get squeegees. Twice this week I have used different pumps and the squeegees were junk. About the next time and I will use a different station

  Shannon Seymour
3 years ago
The service was great, I ordered a salad and wasn't expecting it to be the best salad hands down I have ever had!

  Matthew Allie
3 years ago
Best pizza from a gas station I've ever had!!

  Grady's Crew
5 years ago
Great food I just wish the people didn't look depressed killed the vib.

  dorendra rana
4 years ago
They look at your face and give you service my foot friendly staff no wonder where white employees work it happens kind of racist huh..

  Crystal Hopper
5 years ago
Great pizza and good staff

  Katie Ore
5 years ago
Casey s pizza is awesome! Best in town!

  Jessica Hale
3 years ago
A nice spot to stop and load up on junk!

  Meagan
a year ago
Never answers the phone. Ever.

  Jorgelande Johns
3 years ago
Quick and easy. Get what you need!

  Tom Shelton
8 years ago
We love casey's pizza

  mark rush
3 years ago
Always Great Service!

  Grady Ohara
3 years ago
No delivery common man

  Katie Byrd
a year ago
Decent

  Brigitte Boyce
3 years ago
Great pizza

  ENIGMA {Music}
3 years ago
Omg

  Kyle Waller
6 years ago
Courteous employees

  G�era Victoria
a year ago
Yo solo quiero decir que deber�an de tener m�s cuidado con la vitrina de donas ya que se meten los mosquitos y se ace enjambre ..le he dicho a la cajera y solo dice que no los an podido sacar de la vitrina yo he tenido que sacarlos y no compro nada de donas..agan que las puertas cierren completamente ya que los animales buscan cualquier rendija y se vuelan para adentro..

  Salvador Figueroa
3 years ago
Very goodMuy bien

  Miraida Andino
3 years ago
I likedMe gust�

  Shannon Wood
3 years ago
Fast. Well!Fast. Bueno!