Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Reviews
Reviews are sorted by relevance, with the most helpful and insightful feedback listed first for easy reference.
Anita Western
2 weeks ago
We brought in our '95 Suburban diesel for a scheduled appointment, which took three weeks to secure, but this delay was understandable given they close for spring break to spend time with their families. I opted to wait rather than leave and they fixed the issue within three hours. The pricing for both diagnosis and repair was reasonable. Moreover, the mechanic explained each step of the process and displayed the faulty wire. Overall, we recommend their services; however, it's advisable to set clear timing expectations beforehand.
Steve Callum
5 months ago
Exceptional!!!!!!!! I called Lisa (Owner) Monday afternoon, I explained the issue, she said bring it by Tuesday,. Eight O'clock Tuesday I showed up left the car, got a call within hour later from Lisa delivering repair information and cost. Gave her the go a head. Same day Tuesday at 4pm I picked up my car. It's beautiful when a garage does what they say there going to do. Thank you Andy & Dave's garage for the great service.Sincerely Steve C. happy customer, great experience.
Robert Ott
6 months ago
We were in Marathon, passing through when our car broke down. On the advice of a local, I left a message for them, as it was a Sunday afternoon.I received a call from Lisa, and she told me to bring it right over. Luckily I was able to get a room at a local hotel, which was across US1 from the shop. I limped the car over there. They diagnosed my issue within 2 hours of me dropping it off. We worked out the repair details over the phone. They went above and beyond to get me the best price on parts to get us back on the road. We live 6 hours away.I highly recommend Andy and Dave's Garage to anyone that is looking for auto repairs in the Marathon area. They were fast, detailed and, the costs were equal to the work they performed.Lisa and the mechanics were 5 star in all aspects of our issue.
Terry Greene
2 months ago
What a great group of people. Superb service. Reasonable prices. If your a tourist and traveling and find yourself in need of car repair give them a try.
Zack Rogers
10 months ago
Without a doubt the best place in the keys to get your car fixed. 100% the best workers I ve seen and fastest with quality work. Thanks to John my dodge charger is running agin go to Andy and Dave s not muffler man.
allen john
6 months ago
Pricey. Work done lasted less than 2 months. Won't look at the issue without another charge. Very poor customer service. Could not find a way to talk to owner. I don't recommend.
Suzie Church
10 months ago
OMGOSH what professionals! They have worked on my jeep on two different occasions over the last couple of years! They are highly recommended!
Boat Builder
a year ago
These guys are great, well worth the drive from Key West. They're busy, you'll have to make an appointment, two weeks in my case but well worth the wait.
J Faulkner
4 years ago
Andy and Dave s was recommended to me, and they definitely lived up to their reputation! I ve only used them once and I did get a bit lucky, but, I left their shop with my problem fixed and no charges. Same day turn around, honest and reliable shop! They could have easily charged me a half hour rate, but, they simple fixed my small issue, thanked me for choosing them and sent me on my way. That speaks volumes about their mechanics, shop practices, and their values. I highly recommend them for your auto needs! Thank you! Andy and Dave s!
Warren Keller
5 years ago
I didn't wind up doing business with these people but Alicia was so professional and helpful that I had to leave a review. came down here on vacation blew my transmission and they said they would have installed it for me if I brought them the transmission. She even told me of a shipping company I could use. She's been there for several years and sounds like she likes her job which speaks volumes about the culture of the friendly environment which I felt very comfortable with it because of her. They were recommended to me by other folks as well. We'll probably be doing business with them in the near future if I break down.
Silvin chiarizia
4 years ago
I had to leave my Chevy Silverado with them while on vacation in Marathon. The brakes went out while pulling my boat. They told me a brake line was bad and the fittings were different so they had to order them from the factory. ?. I had important doctor visits scheduled for my wife and myself so I said I would leave it. They called a week later to say it was fixed. So my brother drove me down to get it, 350 mi., and it is not fixed. So now I have to tow it home. I am definitely NOT a satisfied customer. I gave them a generous 2 stars, only because they were nice about ripping me off.
Sean
5 years ago
I have a Toyota Tundra that's never needed repairs that weren't either covered under warranty, or after that, was a minor maintenance item I couldn't do myself. So I never needed a mechanic here in Marathon. I suspected the starter was going out on my truck. An unusually big job on this model of truck (requires removal of the exhaust manifold), so I needed a mechanic. A friend who's lived here for decades told me to call Andy & Dave's. Word of warning: They're busy. They weren't able to get me in for a week. It wasn't a huge deal for me because I have alternate transportation. So, if you're in a hurry, you might have to figure something out. If you've spent any time in the Middle Keys, you know everyone here seems to be on "island time". Getting people to keep an appointment is almost impossible. So I was happy that Andy & Dave's made an appointment and got my truck right in, as scheduled. They diagnosed it (I was right), called me with an estimate later that day and when I gave the go-ahead they ordered the part and got it finished the next day. They also came in under the estimate. I highly recommend Andy & Dave's.
Courtney Foster
6 years ago
Used my lunch break to go set up an appointment for an oil change. Turns out everyone there leaves for lunch from 12-1:15, so I left my name and number for them to call me back. Three hours later I get the call and the woman I was trying to speak with was rude, and then hung up on me. Disappointed with this experience as I've heard they are one of the more reliable mechanics in town and I will now be taking my business elsewhere.
Nancy Mcknight
2 years ago
While on vacation, our car started shaking a little. Our hotel suggested Andy & Dave's Garage. They drove it saw it was a bad tire and told my husband where to go for a new tire. Super helpful people! Thank you Andy and Dave's Garage!
Allen Julie
6 years ago
Like the other reviewers here I was really taken aback by the level of rudeness from the lady in the office! it took me 2 weeks to get in for an estimate and she said I was 40 minutes too late for the drop off time and scheduled me for another 2 weeks ! I wasn't saying anything or complaining but she was going on and on about how can I expect her to change the rules for just me and people don't listen to her, she knows she told me! I literally was not saying anything and she's just going on and on because she's been there all these years and she always tells people! why would I wait 2 weeks for an estimate and come 40 minutes late for it if I knew the time limit she didn't say anything about that over the phone ! Worst customer service ever!!!
belkis carmona
6 years ago
Totally disagree with them, after having an appointment 8 days before I take my car with a truck because I can not drave it and they tell me that they did not know that it can not handle because I do not speak English correctly and she doesn't understand anything Of what I explain. Then decides not to receive my vehicle for not having space in the plants and outside it rains, I had to pay the crane to take it to my house. Besides, when I tried to talk to her, she hung up. The one who does not understand anything is me.
Randall Beggs
2 years ago
This is a good garage with an excellent staff. They completed regular maintenance on my Silverado's front and rear differentials. I would go there again for mechanical service.
Tina Rote
a year ago
Everyone here was extremely nice. Got us worked In last minute while we were on vacation. Highly recommend.
Abby Haddock
2 years ago
Great work, very kind staff with excellent customer service, and they get the job done right.
Debbie Davis
2 years ago
Oil change and they caught the fact that I needed new front brakes, always first class operation.
Thomas Moody
6 years ago
Good mechanics the only ones that I would trust to fix my vehicles if I can't do it myself. Like everyone else prices are high
Bretley Birch
3 years ago
Highly recommended by local automotive store...i had front brakes replaced...good experience....professional friendly service...i would recommend
Barbara Anderson
2 years ago
Staff are knowledgeable and efficient. Oil changes are a fast turnover.
Shannon Wiley
2 years ago
VERY nice to have these honest and professional folks here in town. Thanks for getting me rolling again!
Henry Bassett
5 years ago
I was just there to get a Battery for my truck.They where very polite and organized.
Lynne Southwell
5 years ago
Only place we try to take our car . Thanks for always fitting me into their schedule.
Rob Farthing
3 years ago
Best place in Marathon to get your car work done!
VICKI SHEPHERD
4 years ago
Excellent customer service and fair pricing on repairs
Gene Howland
5 years ago
An RV owner's best friend in the Florida Keys!!!
LA Woodhouse
5 months ago
Best in the Keys